On Mon, 7 Oct 2002 15:58:05 -0700, Gary <geeman@SOFTHOME.NET> wrote:
…
>I`ve fired a LOT of bows and crossbows in my time, and my personal take on
the subject is that they certainly improved crossbows in 3e, but they still
aren`t “realistic” in many regards. One thing that I thought was a good
>addition to the 1e-2e rules was the “point blank” concept that was
>sometimes used. Unfortunately, the rule itself was a little unwieldy for
>practical use when playing out combat, but it was the kernal of a good idea.
>At 12:04 AM 10/8/2002 +0200, Carl Cramer wrote:
>>We let crossbows cause auto-criticals on any threat roll that is also a hit
>>within 30 ft. That way, anyone with a crossbow has at least a 5% chance of
>>inflicting a critical hit - which makes them pretty dangerous militia
>>weapons.
>
>Now, that`s a very interesting additional rule. I like it. It
incorporates the aforementioned “point blank” concept but is much easier to
handle. Kudos.
Also, we allow crossbows to scale freely in size. That gives quite a
varietyof crossbows:
Hand crossbow: T: 1d4, S: 1d6, M: 1d8 - short range, one-handed
Light crossbow: S: 1d8, M: 2d6, L: 2d8 - medium range, quick to reload
Heavy Crossbow: M 1d10, L: 2d6 - long range, slow reload
What do you mean by those reload times? 1 per round and 1/2 per round per
the core rules, or is it something else?
We also made the Hand Crossbow a martial weapon (at least for Ainureans),
and it is qute a common cavalry weapon - check the illustration on the
cavalry war cards.
That seems sensible. Any particular cultures that use the hand crossbow
other than Anuireans? I`d probably limit it to Anuirean, Brecht and maybe
>the Khinasi, personally.
>Gary
It is quite some time since this thread, but I wanted to add something to
the crossbow discussion that bothered me.
The 2E Birthright specific rule did not increase the damage done, as does
the abovementioned houserule which lets crossbows cause auto-critical hits.
It did make causing damage easier.
The 3E houserule does not make inflicting damage easier, but lets it do more
damage on average as the chance for critical hits is higher. And 3E already
raised the damage of crossbows as compared to the 2E crossbows.
The major difference I see is that with the 2E version a commoner would have
had a chance to inflict damage to a full-plate-armoured knight as his
chances to penetrate the armour would have been much better than as compared
to shooting a bow.
The 3E equivalent, the 1st level Commoner shooting the crossbow has a higher
chance to do more damage - but the chance that he actually does any damage
at all is low as he is unlikely to hit at all. If the Commoner in question
is proficient with the crossbow (he has proficiency with 1 simple weapon
according to the 3.0 DMG) he has only a chance of a D20 compared to the AC
of 18 of the knight in full plate armour, so 10% to hit and a 5% to hit and
do a critical hit using the houserule from above. If the commoner has not
used his 1 simple weapon proficiency on crossbow, then he suffers a -4
penalty for not being proficient and is able to hit only on a 20 with a 5%
to hit and automatically do a critical hit.
This does IMO not reflect the threat that let the pope ban crossbows as
weapons that could kill an armoured knight fired from the hands of a peasant.
I would prefer a version that makes it possible for a commoner to fire a
crossbow and penetrate plate armour, not one that in the rare cases that he
actually hits makes more damage.
bye
Michael