BR Crossbows.

On Mon, 7 Oct 2002 15:58:05 -0700, Gary <geeman@SOFTHOME.NET> wrote:

…

>I`ve fired a LOT of bows and crossbows in my time, and my personal take on

the subject is that they certainly improved crossbows in 3e, but they still

aren`t “realistic” in many regards. One thing that I thought was a good

>addition to the 1e-2e rules was the “point blank” concept that was

>sometimes used. Unfortunately, the rule itself was a little unwieldy for

>practical use when playing out combat, but it was the kernal of a good idea.

>At 12:04 AM 10/8/2002 +0200, Carl Cramer wrote:

>>We let crossbows cause auto-criticals on any threat roll that is also a hit

>>within 30 ft. That way, anyone with a crossbow has at least a 5% chance of

>>inflicting a critical hit - which makes them pretty dangerous militia

>>weapons.

>

>Now, that`s a very interesting additional rule. I like it. It

incorporates the aforementioned “point blank” concept but is much easier to

handle. Kudos.

Also, we allow crossbows to scale freely in size. That gives quite a

varietyof crossbows:

Hand crossbow: T: 1d4, S: 1d6, M: 1d8 - short range, one-handed

Light crossbow: S: 1d8, M: 2d6, L: 2d8 - medium range, quick to reload

Heavy Crossbow: M 1d10, L: 2d6 - long range, slow reload

What do you mean by those reload times? 1 per round and 1/2 per round per

the core rules, or is it something else?

We also made the Hand Crossbow a martial weapon (at least for Ainureans),

and it is qute a common cavalry weapon - check the illustration on the

cavalry war cards.

That seems sensible. Any particular cultures that use the hand crossbow

other than Anuireans? I`d probably limit it to Anuirean, Brecht and maybe

>the Khinasi, personally.

>Gary

It is quite some time since this thread, but I wanted to add something to

the crossbow discussion that bothered me.

The 2E Birthright specific rule did not increase the damage done, as does

the abovementioned houserule which lets crossbows cause auto-critical hits.

It did make causing damage easier.

The 3E houserule does not make inflicting damage easier, but lets it do more

damage on average as the chance for critical hits is higher. And 3E already

raised the damage of crossbows as compared to the 2E crossbows.

The major difference I see is that with the 2E version a commoner would have

had a chance to inflict damage to a full-plate-armoured knight as his

chances to penetrate the armour would have been much better than as compared

to shooting a bow.

The 3E equivalent, the 1st level Commoner shooting the crossbow has a higher

chance to do more damage - but the chance that he actually does any damage

at all is low as he is unlikely to hit at all. If the Commoner in question

is proficient with the crossbow (he has proficiency with 1 simple weapon

according to the 3.0 DMG) he has only a chance of a D20 compared to the AC

of 18 of the knight in full plate armour, so 10% to hit and a 5% to hit and

do a critical hit using the houserule from above. If the commoner has not

used his 1 simple weapon proficiency on crossbow, then he suffers a -4

penalty for not being proficient and is able to hit only on a 20 with a 5%

to hit and automatically do a critical hit.

This does IMO not reflect the threat that let the pope ban crossbows as

weapons that could kill an armoured knight fired from the hands of a peasant.

I would prefer a version that makes it possible for a commoner to fire a

crossbow and penetrate plate armour, not one that in the rare cases that he

actually hits makes more damage.

bye

Michael

Keep in mind too that there is another point that, when looked at from a non-game mechanic standpoint, increase the deadliness.

Simple Weapon. This means that almost anyone can be trained to use this weapon. In non-game terms, this means that the weapons could be passed out to peasants, and with a bare minimum of training they could point and shoot this weapon, as opposed to the years of practice needed to use a longbow.

Looking at it from a game standpoint, the Light Crossbow and the Longbow both do an equivalent amont of damage. The Heavy Crossbow does, on average, 1 point more damage per hit, virtually guaranteeing the death of an average soldier when hit by the weapon. Both crossbows are simple weapons, and this are much more dangerous in the hands of rabble. The advantage of the Light Crossbow is a similar rate of fire to a Longbow.

Boy do I have a problem with that bit of the rules. I`ve used light

crossbows, short and long bows in SCA combat and target shooting and

there is no way they can compare speed-wise.

With the clubs archery competition, there is a speed round of 30 seconds

which Ill use for the comparison. With a short bow the best Ive

gotten was 14 shots into the target, though 12 was more usual. The best

I think I managed with the crossbow was 5. That`s 2-3 shots per 6

second round (3/2 rate) with the short bow and 1 per round with the

light crossbow.

While this is just a personal gripe with rules vs. reality, if you are

thinking of modifying the rules to suit such things, you may wist to

consider it.

Regards,

Doyle.

-----Original Message-----

From: Athos69

<snip>

… The advantage of the Light Crossbow is a similar rate of fire to a

Longbow.

Err… Whoever wrote those notes on crossbows (except for Doyle) was pretty much confused when it comes to both rules and reality: a crossbow is VERY slow to reload, while the bow is as fast as you can get an arrow from a quiver, knock it on the bow, then fire! There is a feat that many of you might have liked, Rapid Reload, which allowed one to reload a hand/light crossbow as a free action once per round, or a heavy crossbow as a move action. That rounds up as a maximum of 2 shots per round for the hand/light crossbow and 1 shot per round for the heavy crossbow!

As for realism, the problem is not the ruling for crossbows: the problem lies with the fact that armour normally reduces the possibility of getting hit (armour bonus) only slightly, but most importantly reduces the overall damage dealt by a blow, with a slight weakness against one form of attack, like the characteristic problem chainmail had with piercing weapons, like daggers, rapiers, longswords (not broadswords), gladii, spears, and morningstars (damage reduction).

Here is one thing about bows.

Armour piercing

a knigth in full plate is not save from a hail of armour pierching arrows.

the armour pierching arrow is stha standard for combat. While the hunting arrow is the standard for hunting.

Im not sure How I sould handle this houserule

I imagen the armour pierching arrow will ignor any armour, But not shield.
I imagen thet the armour pierching arrow will ignor natural armour as well.

Can i use the benifit of armour pierching arrows at point blanck?
Can crossbow bolts be armour pierching?
Can shortbow bolts be armour pierching?
Can only longbow arrows be armour pierching?


On related notes, anyone tretening you with a crosbow should be a real treat, no mater who you are. shoul be similar to a modern day shot gun,

Interesting topic, since BR Crossbows specifically got a bonus vs. armor

at short and medium ranger under 2E. No other weapon did, and if carried

over to 3E, would make the Crossbow a very effective weapon, especially

considering its status as a Simple weapon.

However, if the crossbow bolt is piercing at short ranges, then surely a

pick head also is. What about axes then, they certainly have better

piercing capabilities than light swords.

In the end, I think it boils down to 3E using a very abstract system for

defense and damage. The crossbow bolts power is already figured into its

range, damage dice, critical range/multiplier, status as a simple weapon

etc. The same goes for very other weapon.

If one were to want to use armor piercing for weapons, I think that is

should be applied to the system as a whole, but that would be quite a

task to rework it into a viable system.

Cheers

Bjørn

I have already worked the concept of armour piercing for the STANDARD 3e/3.5e system of armour class ratings:
[ul]
[li]Armour piercing missiles effectively reduce the Armour Class rating of the target.[/li][li]I based the armour piercing arrows on the japanese arrows and british bodkin arrows, which both had the same quality, if overall different: they could slice through armour like butter.[/li][li]Armour piercing arrows/bolts are always masterwork.[/li][li]The number by which the opponent’s AC rating is lowered goes as follows:[/li][list]
[li]Armour piercing arrows, shot from a longbow, reduce the AC rating by 2,…[/li][li]… or 1, if shot from a shortbow.[/li][li]Crossbows (except for hand crossbows) always have an armour piercing quality: light crossbows reduce the AC rating by 1,…[/li][li]… heavy crossbows by 2,…[/li][li]… and arbalests by 3.[/li][li]Special armour piercing bolts lower the AC rating by an additional 1.[/li][/ul]
[/list]

Originally posted by RaspK_FOG@Jan 8 2004, 07:17 AM
Armour piercing arrows/bolts are always masterwork.

Overall this seems pretty straight forward to me.

The one comment would be that armor piercing arrows should have the cost of being masterwork but not also gain the masterwork benefit.

That is a masterwork arrow gets a +1 to hit and as presented for the same cost the arrow also gains armor piercing quality.

Another tact could be to parallel the ‘keen’ ability when used against armor (i.e., increased critical range). Just a thought.

irdeggman schrieb:

> This post was generated by the Birthright.net message forum.

> You can view the entire thread at:

> http://www.birthright.net/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=2178

> irdeggman wrote:

>

> Overall this seems pretty straight forward to me.

> The one comment would be that armor piercing arrows should have the cost of being masterwork

> but not also gain the masterwork benefit.

> That is a masterwork arrow gets a +1 to hit and as presented for the same cost the arrow

>also gains armor piercing quality.

> Another tact could be to parallel the keen ability when used against armor (i.e.,

> increased critical range). Just a thought.

The Arms&Equipment guide listed another type of arrow, the flight arrow.

For the benefit that the range increment is increase by 25 feet the

flightarrow does only double critical damage (as compared to the PHB 3.0

X3), and weighs more with 1/5 lb. or 0,2 lb per arrow (the PHB has 20

arrows for 3 lb, only 0,15 per arrow. Finally the Flight Arrow costs 8

gp, while the normal Masterwork Arrow only 7 gp and normal arrows are 20

for 1 gp.

However the Flight Arrow is a masterwork arrow and gains the normal

masterwork benefits.

In my opinion a armourpiercing masterwork arrow should gain the normal

masterwork benefit as well in addition to the armourpiercing as does the

Flight Arrow. Naturally the AP arrow should then also like the Flight

arrow cost more than the normal 7 gp masterwork arrow, better even more

than the flight arrow, and weigh more, perhaps more than the flight arrow.

For normal adventurers starting with the PHB random starting gold (240

gp maximum for a fighter) they are too expensive to use anyway or else

they have no money for any other equipment. And for characters with

enough money to afford them there is still the problem to find someone

with enough skill in Craft (Bowmaking or Fletcher?) to beat the DC 20

for making a masterwork item.

bye

Michael

Sorry, Irdeggman, for not making things clear, as I should.

Armour piercing arrows should always be considered to be masterwork, but cost more as well. The average (market) cost of a bodkin arrow should be from 15 to 50 gp, based on the availability of the item in regard to conditions, not economy. Troops who have to fight against foreigners that favour heavy armour would be carrying more bodkin arrows than any rich perfectionist who is hunting.

----- Original Message -----

From: “RaspK_FOG” <brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET>

Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2004 6:17 AM

> I have already worked the concept of armour piercing for the STANDARD

3e/3.5e system of armour class ratings:

There needs to be some specification of range. All projectile weapons,

gunpowder included, lose velocity (hence kinetic energy) because of wind

resistance. This also explains why projectiles have an arc trajectory. The

old BR materials gave the crossbow a benefit at close and medium range. In

3e a benefit during the first two range increments makes sense for longbows

and crossbows. I would restrict shortbows to 30 yds, because the number of

accounts of their not penetrating even light armors are so numerous. I

would also assume that all arrows shot at armored targets are using armor

piercing arrows. Other kinds of arrows would be obviously inappropriate.

Kenneth Gauck

kgauck@mchsi.com

But why the extremely high cost? It`s about the cost of magic arrows.

The arrows we are talking about are just arrows with narrow heads so

that the kinetic energy of the arrow is concentrated on a smaller area

and is thus better able to penetrate armor.

-----Original Message-----

From: Birthright Roleplaying Game Discussion

[mailto:BIRTHRIGHT-L@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM] On Behalf Of RaspK_FOG

Sent: 8. januar 2004 23:23

To: BIRTHRIGHT-L@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM

Subject: Re: BR Crossbows. [2#2178]

This post was generated by the Birthright.net message forum.

You can view the entire thread at:

http://www.birthright.net/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=2178

RaspK_FOG wrote:

Sorry, Irdeggman, for not making things clear, as I

should.

Armour piercing arrows should always be considered to be masterwork,

but cost more as well. The average (market) cost of a bodkin arrow

should be from 15 to 50 gp, based on the availability of the item in

regard to conditions, not economy. Troops who have to fight against

foreigners that favour heavy armour would be carrying more bodkin arrows

than any rich perfectionist who is hunting.



Birthright-l Archives:

http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html

A side note:

Somewhere in the evolution of D&D between the original published works and

2nd Ed, the crossbow was severely weakened as a weapon - especially in

comparison to bows. In original D&D (i.e. not “Original D&D” the product)

all missile weapons except crossbows were limited to 1-3 damage beyond short

range. By AD&D (1st Ed), all other missile weapons had been greatly boosted

in effectiveness by allowing all to inflict the same damage at all ranges,

and, the number of attacks for most non-crossbow missile weapons effectively

increased (by a factor of 3 in the case of bows!).

[Javelins also became relatively less effective, especially in comparison to

other hurled weapons.]

It would be more correct to say that bows and most other missile weapons

were boosted, while crossbows were not.

Now I personally believe that the boost was mostly unintentional (a boo

boo), and that it was better left the way it was. Of course no-one in

publishing likes to admit they got it wrong and it`s politically almost

impossible to take a bonus back - someone will always howl. But bows became

more than twice as damaging at short range as longswords are in melee -

think about that - a short bow at 50 yards or a longsword at 3 feet - what

is more threatening?

BR (2nd Ed) beefed up the crossbow. Just a bit, although the BR crossbow is

still less powerful relative to bows than original D&D crossbows and

original D&D bows.

original D&D: crossbow 7 bow 12 – ratio 1.7

2nd Ed AD&D: crossbow 7 bow 21 – ratio 3.0

BR 2nd Ed: crossbow 8.4 bow 21 – ratio 2.5

Peter

----- Original Message -----

From: “Kenneth Gauck” <kgauck@MCHSI.COM>

To: <BIRTHRIGHT-L@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM>

Sent: Friday, January 09, 2004 9:12 AM

Subject: Re: BR Crossbows. [2#2178]

> ----- Original Message -----

> From: “RaspK_FOG” <brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET>

> Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2004 6:17 AM

>

>

> > I have already worked the concept of armour piercing for the STANDARD

> 3e/3.5e system of armour class ratings:

>

> There needs to be some specification of range. All projectile weapons,

> gunpowder included, lose velocity (hence kinetic energy) because of wind

> resistance. This also explains why projectiles have an arc trajectory.

The

> old BR materials gave the crossbow a benefit at close and medium range.

In

> 3e a benefit during the first two range increments makes sense for

longbows

> and crossbows. I would restrict shortbows to 30 yds, because the number

of

> accounts of their not penetrating even light armors are so numerous. I

> would also assume that all arrows shot at armored targets are using armor

> piercing arrows. Other kinds of arrows would be obviously inappropriate.

>

> Kenneth Gauck

> kgauck@mchsi.com

Kenneth Gauck schrieb:

> ----- Original Message -----

> From: “RaspK_FOG” <brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET>

> Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2004 6:17 AM

>> I have already worked the concept of armour piercing for the STANDARD

> 3e/3.5e system of armour class ratings:

> There needs to be some specification of range. All projectile weapons,

> gunpowder included, lose velocity (hence kinetic energy) because of wind

> resistance. This also explains why projectiles have an arc trajectory. The

> old BR materials gave the crossbow a benefit at close and medium range. In

> 3e a benefit during the first two range increments makes sense for longbows

> and crossbows. I would restrict shortbows to 30 yds, because the number of

> accounts of their not penetrating even light armors are so numerous. I

> would also assume that all arrows shot at armored targets are using armor

> piercing arrows. Other kinds of arrows would be obviously inappropriate.

> Kenneth Gauck

> kgauck@mchsi.com

All arrows shot at armoured targets should be armourpiercing arrows?

If the armourpiercing arrow/bolt is a masterwork arrow with a cost of at

least 8 gp, likely more, for only 1 arrow, while the normal arrows cost

1 gp for 20, or 0,05 then that means 160 times the price. Would not the

muster and maintenace cost of archers/crossbowmen raise dramatically if

they were equipped with such expensive ammunition, and perhaps even the

supply in numbers large enough simply not possible as not enough

fletchers exist that are able to create masterwork ammunition instead of

normal arrows?

However as replacement for +1, +2 or other arrows that are normally

found in treasure while adventuring in D&D they would seem more

approbiate for Birthright.

Björn wrote:

> But why the extremely high cost? It`s about the cost of magic arrows.

> The arrows we are talking about are just arrows with narrow heads so

> that the kinetic energy of the arrow is concentrated on a smaller area

> and is thus better able to penetrate armor.

In the 3.0 PHB the price for the masterwork arrow in table 8-14 is 350

gp for 50 arrows (the normal 7 gp per masterwork arrows as requirement

for a magical arrow) plus from table 8-10 the price for the + bonus

which in case of +1 Arrows is 2000 gp. A price of 2350 gp for 50 arrows

+1 would be 47 gp for one. And that is only for standard D&D - in

Birthright in which magical equipment is rarer and more expensive that

might be more, for example if using the optional rule which raises the

market price for magic item creation.

15-50 gp for an armourpiercing masterwork arrow as RaspK_FOG suggested

would then not be as expensive as magical arrows +1 and easier available.

However they ought to be nearly as expensive as magical arrows +1 as

their bonus is comparably high, just not magical.

bye

Michael

But as I also pointed out, why would they be masterwork arrows at all? Any competent pair of smith/fletcher in a culture who has evolved arrows to deal with heavy armor, should be able to make arrows of any appropriate kind without them being masterwork.

>

> Fra: Michael Romes <Archmage@T-ONLINE.DE>

> Dato: 2004/01/09 Fri AM 06:55:51 CET

> Til: BIRTHRIGHT-L@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM

> Emne: Re: BR Crossbows. [2#2178]

>

> Kenneth Gauck schrieb:

> > ----- Original Message -----

> > From: “RaspK_FOG” <brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET>

> > Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2004 6:17 AM

> >> I have already worked the concept of armour piercing for the STANDARD

> > 3e/3.5e system of armour class ratings:

> > There needs to be some specification of range. All projectile weapons,

> > gunpowder included, lose velocity (hence kinetic energy) because of wind

> > resistance. This also explains why projectiles have an arc trajectory. The

> > old BR materials gave the crossbow a benefit at close and medium range. In

> > 3e a benefit during the first two range increments makes sense for longbows

> > and crossbows. I would restrict shortbows to 30 yds, because the number of

> > accounts of their not penetrating even light armors are so numerous. I

> > would also assume that all arrows shot at armored targets are using armor

> > piercing arrows. Other kinds of arrows would be obviously inappropriate.

> > Kenneth Gauck

> > kgauck@mchsi.com

>

> All arrows shot at armoured targets should be armourpiercing arrows?

> If the armourpiercing arrow/bolt is a masterwork arrow with a cost of at

> least 8 gp, likely more, for only 1 arrow, while the normal arrows cost

> 1 gp for 20, or 0,05 then that means 160 times the price. Would not the

> muster and maintenace cost of archers/crossbowmen raise dramatically if

> they were equipped with such expensive ammunition, and perhaps even the

> supply in numbers large enough simply not possible as not enough

> fletchers exist that are able to create masterwork ammunition instead of

> normal arrows?

>

> However as replacement for +1, +2 or other arrows that are normally

> found in treasure while adventuring in D&D they would seem more

> approbiate for Birthright.

>

> Björn wrote:

> > But why the extremely high cost? It`s about the cost of magic arrows.

> > The arrows we are talking about are just arrows with narrow heads so

> > that the kinetic energy of the arrow is concentrated on a smaller area

> > and is thus better able to penetrate armor.

>

> In the 3.0 PHB the price for the masterwork arrow in table 8-14 is 350

> gp for 50 arrows (the normal 7 gp per masterwork arrows as requirement

> for a magical arrow) plus from table 8-10 the price for the + bonus

> which in case of +1 Arrows is 2000 gp. A price of 2350 gp for 50 arrows

> +1 would be 47 gp for one. And that is only for standard D&D - in

> Birthright in which magical equipment is rarer and more expensive that

> might be more, for example if using the optional rule which raises the

> market price for magic item creation.

> 15-50 gp for an armourpiercing masterwork arrow as RaspK_FOG suggested

> would then not be as expensive as magical arrows +1 and easier available.

> However they ought to be nearly as expensive as magical arrows +1 as

> their bonus is comparably high, just not magical.

> bye

> Michael

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

Cheers

Bjørn


WebMail fra Tele2 http://www.tele2.no


----- Original Message -----

From: “Michael Romes” <Archmage@T-ONLINE.DE>

Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2004 11:55 PM

> All arrows shot at armoured targets should be armourpiercing arrows?

Yes

> If the armourpiercing arrow/bolt is a masterwork arrow with a cost of

> at least 8 gp, likely more, for only 1 arrow, while the normal arrows

> cost 1 gp for 20, or 0,05 then that means 160 times the price.

Well, then don`t make that assumption. Assume instead that in a combat game

where hobgoblins and orogs wear armor, and they are the typical targets, not

deer, birds, or rabbits, that war-type arrows are the arrows listed in the

PHB. Then if you like, you can make non-war arrows cheaper and less

effective than PHB arrows.

Kenneth Gauck

kgauck@mchsi.com

----- Original Message -----

From: “Green Knight” <bjorn.sorgjerd@C2I.NET>

Sent: Friday, January 09, 2004 1:49 AM

> But as I also pointed out, why would they be masterwork arrows at

> all? Any competent pair of smith/fletcher in a culture who has evolved

> arrows to deal with heavy armor, should be able to make arrows of

> any appropriate kind without them being masterwork.

Absolutly. Check out this page and tell me that one kind is 20x more costly

than another kind of arrow.

http://www.longbow42.giointernet.co.uk/page6.htm

Kenneth Gauck

kgauck@mchsi.com

Well, above all, costs are something you can either keep it or leave it, but I am working with both logic and game balance in mind here:
[ul]
[li]If bodkin arrows had a cost lower than a masterwork arrow, they would be cheaper versions of the exact same thing, as a reduction to a target’s Armour Class is almost the same as an equal increase to your Attack Bonus![/li][li]The second reason (the realistic one) is that masterwork items take more time to make, and you don’t expect me to believe you can make too many bodkin arrows in one day![/li][/ul]

Having suffered through this lecture (not the post but from one of my co-players/DMs) a uncountable number of times - historically there was no hand held missile weapon as effective against armored opponents as was the English longbow, not even any sort of crossbow.

The simple reason to have banned crossbows from use was that, while more complicated to make than a shortbow, they could be used by the common man very effectively - they are a point and shoot weapon that for the most part ignores weather conditions and require little training to operate effectively.

This is the same reason that spears were much more common than were swords - easier to use. Of course making spears was also cheaper than swords, but the mass produced and use without extensive training principles apply.

Here`s another site with some interesting graphics of arrowheads that might

help visualize some of the issues being presented here:

http://www.hectorcoleironwork.com/Arrowheads.html

It`s certainly not definitive or anything, but presents a nice variation.

One thing that I don`t think has been brought up in this thread is that

when it comes to designing arrowheads for use in war there is an inherit

trade off. Arrows meant to pierce armor require thinner, pointed

arrowheads. I`m going to refer to hunting arrows (or ones used against

less heavily armored targets) as broadheads–the triangular arrowhead that

most of us think of when we think of arrows falls into this category. The

important qualities of the broadhead are twofold. First, the “blades” of

the arrowhead create a wider, more devastating wound when striking the soft

tissue of a target. (Some modern broadheads used for hunting, BTW, have

three or four blades for exactly this reason.) Second, a thicker arrowhead

makes the arrow more difficult to remove from the target without causing

yet more damage. The important thing about this is that these two

considerations are, by definition, opposing values. One can`t fully

exploit the potential of piercing AND the damaging effects of a broadhead

at the same time.

With that in mind, I don`t think we should assume that all D&D arrows are

“war arrows” in the sense that they are of the thinner, more pointed

“bodkin” type designed to be used against heavily armored opponents. More

sensible IMO would be to assume that the standard D&D arrow is somewhere in

the middle of those two opposing extremes. It is a “medium broadhead” with

a thickened central point, but is in most respects a compromise between the

two designs. It`s 1d8 damage (for a medium longbow) with x3 critical

expresses that nicely IMO, especially since it allows us to do some

variations. For instance, when it comes to portraying these differences

I`d suggest the following might make the most sense: An arrow with a

bodkin head might have its critical damage reduced to x2, while an arrow

with a broader head might have it`s critical threat improved to

19-20/x3. Costs for such arrows should remain the same as for standard arrows.

Gary