Chap 2 Blood Score Proposals (Revised)

Here is the vote for which proposal to pursue for blood score.

The link for the proposals is http://www.tuarhievel.org/Blood%20Score%20…sals%205-15.zip

I included a listing for a combination of 2 proposals - so if you think that is the best way to go, then post which combination you’d like to see. This is not referring to variants but rather a combined proposal, for example proposal A with the scion class descriptions more like those in proposal D, or something like that.

I will be looking for a clear majority, something along the lines of twice as many favoring one orf the proposals. It is also entirely possible that more than one would be selected, one default and one as a variant.

Note that this is really independent of anything that 3.5 might affect so don’t worry about 3.5’s impact on the blood score - although it may affect the blood abilities themselves, but we’ll deal with that bridge when we come to it.

I would prefer the revised BRCS (your) version as my favourite.

Otherwise geeman’s idea is nice too…

I have voted for D - the feat like approach.

The revised BRCS version loses much of it’s inherent simplicity by doubling the stat for no real reason other than a sense of backwards compatibility.

The experience points method relies on probability balancing for its bloodline strength - this is against the tenents of 3rd edition as seen in the revision of psionics.

The blood-points system would seem to have the most potential, and I do like the clear descriptions of what you get for you for your invested points in each ability. However the inclusion of fractional ECLs, redundant arithmetic and multiple generated attributes (strength, score, points) make the system opaque and initially confusing. If this system was simplified and re-written for clarity, even at the expense of simulation accuracy, it would be a clear winner for me, but for the moment, no.

Finally, I selected the feat-like approach - but reluctantly. This is solely because of the inclusion for the Scion class - which I am wholly against. I would be much happier if the Noble class gained access to these feats, and the template method was used, but as is it is the lesser evil of the four choices.

CM.

3 +0200, CMonkey wrote:

>The blood-points system would seem to have the most potential, and I do

>like the clear descriptions of what you get for you for your invested

>points in each ability. However the inclusion of fractional ECLs,

>redundant arithmetic and multiple generated attributes (strength, score,

>points) make the system opaque and initially confusing. If this system was

>simplified and re-written for clarity, even at the expense of simulation

>accuracy, it would be a clear winner for me, but for the moment, no.

As for the multiple steps in generating attributes, I dont think theres

much to do about that. Pretty much all the proposals as well as the

original system had that. I`d really hate to eliminate a step by doing

something like equating bloodline strength with bloodline score since I

think thats one of the faults of the playtests system of bloodline being

an ability score. By themselves the steps (3d6-2, d6 x Bloodline Strength

value, spend BP on blood abilities) are bit more effort to go to than other

systems–mostly in the area of spending BP, but since that`s one of the

points in the system I dont think theres much for it. Maybe an example

of character generation would help…

The decimal ECL aspect of the blood ability point system, however,

definitely seems to be the thing people take issue with most. That`s

understandable, I suppose, if for no other reason than because it`s the

thing that departs most from the typical 3e/d20 rules. The math is really

quite simple, but I think it`s just too much of a departure from the rules

set for most people`s taste, particularly since it covers just that single

aspect of BR characters. If decimal values were included in the standard

stuff for characters in 3e, or if it accompanied a whole system of variable

XP (which is how I envision it–picture things like a 1st level spell slot

equal to a 0.1 modifier on XP required to take a level, 2nd level 0.2,

etc.) then I think it would be more acceptable and more easily digested,

but on its own I think people find it too much detail in the name of

accuracy and balance than is warranted.

One possibility is making the ECL modifier for bloodline scores based on

the “average” bloodline strength that one needs to get that score and just

round them to whole numbers. Or, I suppose, just assign values–which

appears to be how most ECLs are set anyway… Using an “average” ECL

modifier Table 3 would look like this:

Table 3: Bloodline Score

     Bloodline       Bloodline       Maximum

     Score   Points  Abilities       ECL

     1-7     0       0       0

     8-14    1       1       0

     15-21   2       1       1

     22-28   3       2       1

     29-35   4       2       1

     36-42   5       2       1

     43-49   6       3       2

     50-56   7       3       2

     57-63   8       3       2

     64-70   9       4       2

     71-77   10      4       3

     78-84   11      4       3

     85-91   12      5       3

     92-98   13      5       3

     99-105  14      5       4

That way there`s just the one number. Would something like that be better?

Gary

Would something like that be better?

Yes, I think it would.

Thinking about it, I agree with your argument that it’s not more complex, just more different and that is the problem - but unfortunately I think you’re stuck with making it simpler than the more familiar systems to compensate.

On the “redundant arithmetic” I mentioned: why 3d6 - 2 ? The 3d6 (or 4d6-drop-1 nowadays) is the most “comforting” of the familiar D&D generation mechanics. Why not just have the table start at 3?

On clarity and formatting: you can summarise the generation in less than 10 words (“3d6-2, d6 x Bloodline Strength value, spend BP on blood abilities”) and yet in your proposal the reader has to scan 3 pages before they hit the step-summary. Consider on the first page a dominating boxout, reading something like this:
[ul]
[li]Determine heritage strength. This will also determine your bloodline modifier. See Section 1.[/li][li]Determine bloodline score. This will also determine your maximum number of blood abilities and the bloodpoints (BP) you can spend on them. See Section 2.[/li][li]Determine your bloodline derivation. This will determine which blood abilities you can select from. See Section 3.[/li][li]Spend bloodpoints (BP) on blood abilities. See Section 4.[/li][/ul]

Note that I’ve re-named bloodline strength to heritage strength (heresy!) and bloodline points to bloodpoints. This is because, with bloodline strength, bloodline modifier, bloodline score and bloodline points, it seems like there must be redundancy in the system (4 stats for the one attribute?) even though they all serve different purposes. Plus for beginners it is hard to remember which does what when they all have very similar names.

As to the section references, each section could similarly start with a summary boxout with the detail, exceptions and additions in the body text around it.

Hope this all seems constructive!

CM.

By the way Geeman, have you not voted for your own proposal?

CM.

3 +0200, CMonkey wrote:

>

Would something like that be better?

>

> Yes, I think it would.

>

> Thinking about it, I agree with your argument that it`s not more

complex, just more different and that is the problem - but unfortunately

I think you`re stuck with making it simpler than the more familiar

> systems to compensate.

>

> On the “redundant arithmetic” I mentioned: why 3d6 - 2 ? The

> 3d6 (or 4d6-drop-1 nowadays) is the most “comforting” of the

> familiar D&D generation mechanics. Why not just have the table start at 3?

I did it that way for two reasons. The first is because the Bloodline

Score is based on that Bloodline Strength value (d6 rolled once for each

point of that 3d6-2) so making it a simple 3d6 would result in the minimum

bloodline score also being a range of 3d6 (3-18) rather than something

closer to the original BR bloodline system in which it could range as low

as 1. Second, I included a feats in that system that effectively adds +2

to one`s bloodline strength, cancelling the -2, and returning things to the

3-18 “standard.” In my sometimes munchkinny gaming group I fully expected

the players to make use of that feat.

I could still keep it 3d6 and have the bloodline score then rolled up by

rolling a number of dice equal to that value -2. It`s purely cosmetic, but

if it would make more in keeping with D&D methods it`d be a good change.

To be honest, making bloodline “look 3e” is not IMO a very needful or even

a very wise goal. The whole bloodline strength = 3d6 thing was a bit of a

nod towards the first bloodline update by Travis Doom that is, by and

large, the same one in the BRCS playtest. I don`t much like making

bloodline an ability score (in fact, I really think it`s a Bad Idea) but at

that time it seemed to be what everyone wanted to see. I wrote it up in

deference to that, just to see what would come out. Later, I found I kind

of liked the way that aspects of the system worked. The math fell into

line and the dice were mostly the nice cubey ones that I like so much. So

I ended up using it in the later expansion of the bloodline system that

included bloodline points.

Rules mechanically, I think the Bloodline Point stuff more resembles

several D20 texts that have come out in the years between 3.0 and 3.5. (Is

Savage Species 3.4?) Some of the really basic inspiration for it was from

the way the superhero d20 games Four Colors to Fantasy and Mutants &

Masterminds dole out super powers. Anyone familiar with either of those

two systems will probably feel much more at home with blood ability points.

On clarity and formatting: you can summarise the generation in less than

10 words ("3d6-2, d6 x Bloodline Strength value, spend BP on blood

abilities") and yet in your proposal the reader has to scan 3 pages

before they hit the step-summary. Consider on the first page a dominating

boxout, reading something like this:

[ul]

[li]Determine heritage strength. This will also determine your[/li]
bloodline modifier. See Section 1.

[li]Determine bloodline score. This will also determine your[/li]
maximum number of blood abilities and the bloodpoints (BP) you can spend

on them. See Section 2.

[li]Determine your bloodline derivation. This will determine which[/li]
blood abilities you can select from. See Section 3.

[li]Spend bloodpoints (BP) on blood abilities. See Section 4.[/li]
[/ul]

There is a little “Bloodline Determination Checklist” in there that has

those basic steps in, perhaps, more detailed form in order to accommodate

the various details like feats, the requirement of a random method of blood

ability determination, etc. Here it is:

Bloodline Determination Checklist

Below is a step-by-step guide to determining bloodline.

  1. Determine bloodline strength using whatever method the DM assigns (3d6,

4d6 ignore lowest, point buy, etc.) Subtract 2 from that total for a range

of 1-16, and add any bonus from the Ancient Bloodline feat. Compare that

result to Table 1: Bloodline Strength on page 10 to get your bloodline

modifier (bld.)

  1. Determine your bloodline score by rolling d6 for every point of your

bloodline strength. Compare the result to Table 3: Bloodline Score on page

11 to get the number of bloodline points (BP) you may have and the maximum

number of blood abilities possible for your character.

  1. Determine your bloodline derivation. (Either roll randomly on Table 4:

Bloodline Derivation on page 11 or choose one at the DM`s option.)

  1. Spend bloodline points (BP) on blood abilities.

Im not really much of a formatting/editting guy, Im afraid, so I

generally defer to people who have more of a sense for layout and design

than I. Having said that, a box out for those steps would be a good

thing. Moving it up to the front might also be a good plan. In that

bloodline proposals document I think the goal was to format everything as

closely like each other as possible, however, just to let people focus on

the ideas rather than the look of the thing. The original Bloodline Point

System document (I dont know if thats still available on birthright.net)

was more complete and formatted in a way that sort of mimics the original

BR materials. At least, I used the Bebris font for titles…

> Note that I`ve re-named bloodline strength to heritage strength

(heresy!) and bloodline points to bloodpoints. This is because, with

bloodline strength, bloodline modifier, bloodline score and

bloodline points, it seems like there must be redundancy in the

system (4 stats for the one attribute?) even though they all serve

different purposes. Plus for beginners it is hard to remember which does

what when they all have very similar names.

Yeah, the vocabulary is a bit confusing, particularly in the original

materials in which IIRC they sometimes refer to “bloodline strength score”

meaning bloodline strength and things like that. I tried to stay as close

as possible to the original terminology but using “strength” and “score” to

designate the difference between the two. It`s easiest to think of the

different aspects of bloodline as "strength, score, abilities and

points." Unfortunately, if one says “strength” without modifying it with

“bloodline” then one can confuse that with the ability score strength, etc.

Lately, I started thinking that “bloodline strength value” might better

designate the 1-16 number than simply “bloodline strength.” I tried to

define each of those terms separately in the introduction, but only the

first occurrence of the term is italicized, and probably nothing cries out

for a glossary quite so loudly… “Heritage” is an interesting and quite

possibly better term to use overall, so I`ll have to think on that a bit.

As to the section references, each section could similarly start with a

summary boxout with the detail, exceptions and additions in the body text

around it.

Hope this all seems constructive

Very. Thanks.

At 03:01 PM 7/25/2003 +0200, CMonkey also wrote:

By the way Geeman, have you not voted for your own proposal?

Heh. You know, I dont recall.... I _think_ I did. Frankly, Im not

really concerned with whether it makes it into BRCS or not. The stuff I

put out into the BR community is stuff I write for my own purposes. I put

it out there because it might be of help or interest to someone someplace

or because Im curious what other peoples opinions might be on the

subject. Getting into the BRCS stuff would be nice, but it`s not that big

a deal to me. Not to disparage the work of the design team (some of their

material is IMO inspired) but I probably spend as much time rereading the

br-l archives than I do their BRCS and the archives are also more likely to

influence my table top game.

However, having seen the film Election I think I probably should at least

vote for myself, so I`ll make sure I have.

Gary

After reviewing the proposals (now that I finally was able to download them properly), here are my thoughts and suggestions:

I like Mark Aurel’s idea that Charisma can substitute for a Bloodline Score modifier. After all, the 3e PHB describes Charisma as one’s inner power, and it further encourages scions to have a high Charisma - which they should.

In general, I like the BRCS playtest version as is. Most of the proposals seem to make things more complicated, not less so. So far (in my own playtesting) I haven’t found it to unbalance the game or make for ridiculous amounts of math. Some of the proposals look like ways to make the bloodline scores synonomous with the original 2e edition.

I’m generally a fan of random ability score generation, so I don’t run into the “being penalized by starting points” problem that others have talked about with a seventh ability score.

I definitely like the idea of scion class levels (from proposal A) to help balance out the ECL adjustments. Just giving the scions some skill points and hp for each level, along with the existing blood abilities and regent bonus HP, goes a long way toward making those extra levels feel worthwhile.

I wouldn’t cry if the Great Heritage template disappeared. I think True Bloodlines end up competing with Great Heritage for the same spot. Aren’t Great bloodlines already representative of a great heritage?

If scions of Great bloodlines regained access to the bloodline abilities that Great Heritage scions get (like Divine Wrath and Regeneration), it would vindicate their rarity and “greatness,” rather than playing them off as 3rd rate (behind Great Heritage-Great and True bloodlines).

On the other hand, a power like Invulnerability should definitely be limited to True Bloodlines. It’s a truly legendary quality, right out of myths and legends, and thus should be limited to the legendary figures of Cerilia.

As for Bloodtrait and Bloodform as prerequisites: don’t the abilities gained from monster levels already justify many of the special powers inaccessible to normal scions? Why give them exclusive access to blood abilities? I recommend keeping it really simple, and making powers available based solely on the four bloodline strength templates (Minor, Major, Great, True).

That’s my 2 cents (well, maybe 3…).
-Osprey

Originally posted by Osprey@Jul 31 2003, 07:22 PM
In general, I like the BRCS playtest version as is. Most of the proposals seem to make things more complicated, not less so.

Ooo! That makes two of us! Woo!

Unfortunately, dispite winning the last poll, they’re determined to change it :frowning:

Heyho.

CM.

PS.
(Sorry about using “Ooo” and “Woo” in the same sentence. That was excessive. :rolleyes: )

Yeah well, you can’t win 'em all, aye? Still, I can see a less drastic change being appropriate. There are good points to the proposals, I’m just a little miffed at the insistence on making blood scores like the old 2e ones. Is it really a problem to just halve the old scores to make them compatible with new ones? Or are there other problems there that I’m not aware of?
Osprey

i voted for combinaison of method but i wiant voted for C method..oups !

i prefer the C method but the bloodline score seems high no ?
follow method A and follow method B

On the base of method C
optionnal bloodline ( touched and lesser ) , feat and bloodline abilities with bloodline point is good
i see good the change below
And modify the table 3:blloodline score ( for high bloodline points), step by 6 not by 7
And reduce the generation of average bloodline point ( 3D6-2->9->9d6->32 bloodline score !!! in average !), by for example *50% ( 16) or *75% (24)
Add, The detect bloodline strenght of method B is very nice…
And the Hit point bonus of method A but under the form of a feat ( prerequise bloodline strengt > minor )

that’all, it’s my opinion

the system as is, I think the ECLs on the templates

may need tinkering, but otherwise it works fine by me.

Seraphina

DM of Birthright d20 - King of the Giantdowns

http://members.tripod.com/bithrightd20

I support the use of Charisma as a substitue for Bloodline score: it is interesting that most people do not associate it with strength and appealing of character! I mean, so many undead get a bonus to Charisma, I thought people would get the insinuation!

Anyway, my preferences are that either option A or option D are followed:

1) The Bloodline score solution gives a lot of ideas and open themes that can make everything very interesting, and the mechanic seems to work fine with me. One mistake though: since option A’s scion class gives a Hit Die every level (that was what I once mentioned in a thread), level 3’s Base Attack Bonus should be +3, not +2, otherwise the Base Saves would not have increased accordingly.

2) I like the idea of the scion class (and Charisma) a lot, allowing a more flexible effective “ECL” than option A, where your ECL is set. I was told it was based on “Savage Species” (a book I have not yet read) which explains the idiosyncratic 3rd level attributes, but I like the idea none-the-less, if not even more.

Oops! :blink: Change 1)'s 3rd level issue to a 4th level one… Really sorry!!!

I’d have to say that the gist of Option D appeals to me the most. The reason for this is that it does away with the template system, but retains it at the same time, in the form of a class. I think that the basic reason for this class is much better than the class proposed in Option A. There is still some work needing to be done. E.g. why multiply the bloodline score by 1.5?? If the reason is stated I missed it. The scion class variants need work too, but the basic idea seems sound.

I also like the idea of “buying” powers, as in option C. So maybe a combination of the two. I am planning a new campaign in a couple of months, and can tell you with absolute certainty, that I will be looking into this.

If combining the two options, one could imagine that the scion class is responsible for the Bloodpoints for buying powers. I think that would be working very well.

Alternately I think the table by Geeman where the bloodline score is responsible for the ECL modifier is quite interesting.

As a final note, although I am sure that there many interesting improvements in 3.5, I sincerly hope that the BRCS will support 3ed first and foremost. I have no intention of investing i 3.5 myself, as it is my understanding that 3.5 is more of a revised edition which includes errata. With very few exceptions I like 3ed as it is, and see no reason to dole more money than strictly necessary. But that is just me :wink:

If the BRCS takes 3.5 into accound, I would like to request that sections where the content would differ, depending on 3ed and 3.5, state it clearly or states two ways of doing it, or maybe some third possibility.

I’d have to say that the gist of Option D appeals to me the most. The reason for this is that it does away with the template system, but retains it at the same time, in the form of a class. I think that the basic reason for this class is much better than the class proposed in Option A. There is still some work needing to be done. E.g. why multiply the bloodline score by 1.5?? If the reason is stated I missed it. The scion class variants need work too, but the basic idea seems sound.

Not 100% sure on what you mean by the 1.5 multiplication - the point of option D is to use basically similar bloodline scores to the 2e system, and are thus higher than those of the playtest version, and not “ability scores.” If you’re referring to the Great Heritage feat, the reason is to put the initial bloodlines generated in a certain range, whilst also enabling the possibility of a much higher maximum bloodline score level, to account for people roughly as high as Avan and Boeruine, for instance.

If you could point out more specific areas of where you think the scion class variants need work, that’d be great.

As a final note, although I am sure that there many interesting improvements in 3.5, I sincerly hope that the BRCS will support 3ed first and foremost. I have no intention of investing i 3.5 myself, as it is my understanding that 3.5 is more of a revised edition which includes errata. With very few exceptions I like 3ed as it is, and see no reason to dole more money than strictly necessary. But that is just me

Well, the stated goal is to keep the materials current. That said, I don’t think you should have a problem using that material at all - for the purposes of what we’re making, I don’t think there’ll be substantial differences between the original and revised editions - most of those differences are just in the referenced materials (the PHB) anyway, not in the BRCS.

I have only scan some of these post and here is my problem.

  1. Bloodlines are inhereted from generations, based on your characters mother and father right. So then some of these powers will or maybe not manifest themselfs during childhood. So the Feat, and Experiance thing is out the window, because if I run two PC a male and Female and they marry (there both blooded) then of course there child is blooded and no roll is needed for bloodline strength or dervianation.

I feel the original rules weaken the person who is blooded and those who choose not to be blooded well they off to a good start. So what I did was give everyone 32 points to distribute, (i feel birthright is a high powered campaing if you dont then try running in the sword of role sometime), and if the PC wishes to be blooded the he rolls 3d6, and the first number that is 8 or greater is his bloodlind score.

I really dont put any restriction on players that want to be blooded, I mean this is birthright and its what its all about right. To top it all off its more fun for me to mess with the blooded regents being the DM (he he yes I can be evil snicker snicker).

And Finally the Feat for being blooded, now thats a waste of a feat, first of all some poor soul standing in the right place at the right time, bang hes blooded and he automatically gains the bloodline feat, where the poor mage had to use his only feat for being blooded at first level. that sucks.

Again this is Birthright your players are sopose to rub elbows with the royality maybe even marry one, If I wanted to be a commoner working my way up the mage guild then i can play Forggotten Realms, or Greyhawk.

Well thanks for listening

1) Bloodlines are inhereted from generations, based on your characters mother and father right. So then some of these powers will or maybe not manifest themselfs during childhood. So the Feat, and Experiance thing is out the window, because if I run two PC a male and Female and they marry (there both blooded) then of course there child is blooded and no roll is needed for bloodline strength or dervianation.

I think you’re under some misconceptions as to the intents of the various methods here - I don’t think any of the authors intended for blood abilities not to be inheritable (i.e. father has character reading, son has character reading), simply that a mechanical balance must be struck between blooded and unblooded characters (blooded characters shouldn’t be any better than unblooded characters of the same character level).


And Finally the Feat for being blooded, now thats a waste of a feat, first of all some poor soul standing in the right place at the right time, bang hes blooded and he automatically gains the bloodline feat, where the poor mage had to use his only feat for being blooded at first level. that sucks.

Sure it sucks - but that’s what happens when you give away goodies for free. What you really should do is have the guy who gains a bloodline at some later point pay for it with his next feat before he’s allowed to use his blood abilities, if you go that route.

so then an new born baby is born blooded and has a feat.

I made a brainstorming on those ECL’s for bloodlines again. IMO they are still unfair for scions/ nonregents. So I have an idea, but I don’t know if somebody did have it already:

Bloodline ECL:
Minor +0/+0
Major +1/ +0
Great +2/ +1
True +3/ +2

The last ECL number is for non-regent characters. They don’t get several advantages, regents get (example extra hit points)…