Hey Guys,
If I remember right crossbows in AD&D in Birthright were better than common DnD crossbows. Is this in the BRCS?
Sin
Hey Guys,
If I remember right crossbows in AD&D in Birthright were better than common DnD crossbows. Is this in the BRCS?
Sin
Nope.
The rules follow the 3.5 rules as much as possible.
Pretty much only campaign specific weapons got “added”; cutless, sabre, main-gauche and vos warspear. Some appear in “other” WotC products but not in the SRD and were such an inherent part of the setting that they were "added’ specifically.
Also the BR crossbows actually were paralleled in Player’s Option: Combat and Tactics which had the same stats and effects - so essentially the BR crossbows became the “new” standard in D&D after PO: C&T.
Basically the two products were written in parallel (or at least a large overlap occurred).
Does anyone have any house rules that can address the disadvantages of crossbows versus bows within dnd? I mean the damage is about the same and the range as well so it comes down to how many attacks per round you want and is it worth spending a feat on it (if you were a non-martial character).
What are you trying to get?
How crossbows are “weaker” than bows?
How to make crossbows better?
Or just the list of reasons why crossbows aren’t as good as bows?
I mean are you looking for house-rules that make cross bows “better”?
Thanks for the answer. I’ll house rule something. People that have been playing in my birthright games since AD&D know that “In the birthright campaign, crossbows have exceptional penetrating power” according to the old rulebook and it’s an example of how rules should have either been introduced to “all” of DnD OR the setting. I think of birthright as having better crossbows than the rest of DnD, which at the time of my 3 year AD&D birthright game WAS true, particularly when my players shunned the player option books.
it’s an easy fix though.
Thanks
Sin
Try this feat from PHB II.
Crossbow sniper: Apply ½ dex bonus to damage {PHB II}
Hey that’s not bad. Thanks.
Remember that the bonus “to hit” only applied to “armored” opponents and not a general always applicable bonus. And only at medium and short range to boot. Range increments have pretty much wiped out that short and medium range thing though. The general application for “precision” based types of bonuses in general only work within 30 ft nowadays.
Maybe I got my history wrong but I thought most RL armies swtched to the Crossbow from the bow due to the fact that it was easier to train troops to hit a target with a crossbow instead of a bow. Having fired both when I was a kid I remember hitting the bale of hay with the crossbow almost everytime but missing completly with the bow for many shots. (This was within the first two range bands:))
I was looking for something that either made it easier to hit with a crossbow or a rule about mustering crossbowmen or training levies into crossbowmen is easier/cheaper/faster than normal archers (bows). Does this make any sense to anyone else?
The crossbow was the prefered bow in the high middle ages for the reasons you mention, but the development of a compound longbow c.1300 turned English archers into a tremendous combat force. As in all things, the English were immitated, even without the compound bows.
Also, keep in mind that accuracy is nearly irrelevant in war. The “target” is a large body of men called an army, and it is very large. Plus you don’t have to hit anything to cause people to get nervous, take cover, and activate their self-preservation instincts. Put a thousand arrows into the air in the right general direction, and you’re bound to hit something. And even when you hit only a few people, they will take cover during the archery. Its sufficient to keep them huddled under their shields while your cavalry moved down-field towards them.
Of course having good archers is better than having bad archers, but for most medieval armies, bad archers were suffcient, and no effort was made to imporve thier archers’ quality.
Crossbows do have good armor penetration, but their rate of fire is so poor, they basically get one good shot at the begining of a combat, and then they have little use. The French were so contemptueous of their own hired Genoese crossbows that after they would fire, they would ride through them from behind to charge the enemy. Some of this might be distain for mercenaries, foriegners, or even their style of combat, but you can be sure that if they were really effective, they would be respected.
A crossbow can be fired from a prone position - a shortbow can be fired if kneeling but (barring some recurve bows) a longbow needs the wielder to be standing - a 6-7’ bow doesn’t clear the ground otherwise. The crossbow is therefore very useful when hunting wary prey or as a weapon of assassination.
The low rate of fire of a crossbow compared to a longbow is crippling and probably outweighed most other considerations (much like muskets were often preferred over early rifles due to the relatively high rate of fire) - but against heavily armoured opponents the punch of a heavy crossbow can be devastating.
One potential option to represent the advantages of crossbows is to allow crossbows to ignore armour bonuses up to a certain level (whatever works in your campaign) making hits by low level opponents far more likely on tanked up fighter PC’s… After the PC’s get hit a few times they may come to like crossbows themselves.
Personally I like the idea of a ‘dwarven wall’ modeled on the British square (if you’ve seen the Michael Caine film ‘Zulu’ you’ll know what I mean). Dwarves have the discipline necessary for the formation, and should be able to do something similar with crossbows.
One BR training rule would be to allow elite archers (longbowmen) only after a prolonged training time or a decree that all youths must learn the bow. A few months intensive training with the bow should give basic adequacy - more than is necessary for crossbows by far but not much in terms of the time that ancient generals considered necessary to make veterans of peasants (5-10 years from dim recollection).
I have been using these house rules in my BR Campaign.
xbows: +2 hit a close range
Longbows: +2 hit at long range
This is my attempt to use the historical stuff. Crossbows were known to be deadly at close range and easy to use and the longbow was famous in its long range ability to kill.
Xbow vs Bow.
Bow-
cheaper
great for volley attacks
high rate of fire
lighter (easier to transport)
Xbow-
easier to aim (train with)
very good at getting through armour
can be mass produced (in later times, this makes it easier to repair)
So it really comes down to Xbows (IMO) being better for pc who is going to fight a lot of knights or a bow for someone who is going to be fighting more monsters.
I am sure I’m leaving a lot out of this, however 46 hours being up had destroyed my mind tonight. Please forgive my errors.
I currently consider fiddling with the combat system by adding a defence value to class levels and switching to damage reducing armour. In addition, every weapon would gain an armour piercing value, which reduces or eliminates the damage reduction. This system could neatly simulate the penetrating power of crossbows.
So far however, I’m still not quite sure which of several available options to use, and I’m also not sure if I can see all the repercussions this might have on gameplay (for instance, natural armour and touch spells would be certainly influenced). If anyone has experimented with such a system, I would like to hear how this turned out and especially which problems occurred.
As an afterthought however, the reload times for crossbows are really fast, - too fast compared to historical reality, which makes D&D crossbows better than their historical equivalents.
Thanks for the input! You touched on another question I had with this quote. How do you get rid of mercenaries when you no longer need them? I do not think the King/Jarls of Halskapa will charge through their own mercenaries to attack the Siren’s troops. This tatic could work in Anuire (Ghoere) and Khinasi (Binsada) and of course any Goblin/Vos army. But I would think Rjurik (Respect for life) and Brecht (Assets) would treat them better. I would think the Brecht could sell their own mercenaries to neighboring lands but others are left with disbanding them and risking the banditry (sp?) from the fallout.
Steve
My armor class system is here. I have been very satisfied with it.
Riding through the crossbowmen didn’t so much kill them as just disturb them greatly. I don’t think the knights gave them a heads up about their plan to ride through them, they just just did it.
Disbanding mercenaries is always a problem because they tend to just work for themselves (against the local citizenry) when they are discharged. Discharging regulars who served for several years can produce the same effects for soldiers who either don’t want to go home or are too much attached to using force to get their way to return to being a commoner.
Generally incidence of brigandry are connected to poor law enforcement, so you might consider every disbanded unit a contest action against the law holdings of the province (treating the unit as a single law holding). If the conest action is successful, brigands are formed by the disbanded unit. Resolve as the random event “Brigandry”.
There are lots of things that cannot be replicated, unless you accept resorting to either DM fiat or complicated tables. For example, a estoc can easily overcome chainmail, but it would be much less capable of punching through a full plate harness.
If you are going to go that way, first of all, do consider to grant armours a small AC bonus - in reality, that’s half their job, really; there are two kinds of hits that armour protects you from: those that hit solidly but whose momentum is reduced by the armour, and those that would have otherwise connected but do not do so due to the armour, glancing off. The first are represented beautifully by damage reduction mechanics, but the second are not: a good set of armour can glance off even some very powerful blows, but can fail to do so with less powerful but more solid hits.
So, ideally, you should use a damage reduction bonus (yes, this should stack with other DR ratings the creature has), an AC bonus (starting from +0), and you should define how the following 6 kinds of damage interact with them: bashing/crushing, slashing/hacking, and puncturing/piercing (the former of each two is the kind of damage that can be blocked easily by protection, while the latter has greater penetrating power).
For example, a full plate harness is nigh impenetrable from puncturing damage (no pun intented), whereas a piercing weapon (i.e. a spear or lance) can actually punch through it. Likewise, a bashing weapon (i.e. a small club) is of little consequence to anyone wearing such armour, but a crushing weapon (i.e. a warhammer, maul, mace, or the like) are more likely to deliver their damage.
On Nov 26, 2007 6:56 PM, Sinister <brnetboard@birthright.net> wrote:
> If I remember right crossbows in AD&D in Birthright were better than common DnD crossbows. Is this in the BRCS?
Its not necessary. 3e crossbows got a significant power boost. A heavy crossbow does 1d10 19-20/x2 now, and a light does 1d8 19-20/x2. Thats actually better than the 2nd edition BR crossbows. Baseline
2nd edition crossbows only did 1d4 or 1d4+1.
–
Daniel McSorley
In a message dated 11/27/2007 2:38:32 P.M. Eastern Standard Time,
brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET writes:
I was looking for something that either made it easier to hit with a
crossbow or a rule about mustering crossbowmen or training levies into crossbowmen
is easier/cheaper/faster than normal archers (bows). Does this make any
sense to anyone else?
In 3rd ed., crossbows are “simple” weapons, which means nearly all classes
know how to use them without penalty. Bows are “martial” weapons, so only
fighters and the like can use them without penalty (unless they spend the feat
on it, or they have some other special thing). Elves of all kinds can use
bows without penalty.
I would also point out that crossbows have a wider critical threat range
(10%), vs. a bow`s 5%, and have bigger damage dice (d8/d10 vs. d6/d8).
In short, unless you`ve been trained on bows, the crossbow is a much
better weapon.
Lee.
**************************************Check out AOLs list of 2007s hottest
products.
(http://money.aol.com/special/hot-products-2007?NCID=aoltop00030000000001)