On Mon, 1 Sep 2003, zukie51262 wrote:
> Ok here`s my problem my players have holding in the Southern Brect
> lands. They very from trade routes to Law holding, but nothing tied
> to the land as of yet.
And Brechtur is the perfect place to launch the careers of adventurous
merchant princes.
> They went sailing one day (looking at the maps of the land) and
> discovered an Island above the Vos Guard. A nice size island where
> they can have land, holdings and such, just needs to be tamed.
Oho, Torova Temylatin! Think of it this way: there must be reasons that
island, so very close as it is, has never been settled by humans in
thousands of years. The challenges they face should be immense – just
getting to the point at which creating a holding is even remotely possible
ought to take decades of game time, very hard work, the expenditure of
immense resources, and a hell of a lot of luck.
> Now when i informed them to do this they cannot be in both places at
> once to run the holdings in the Brect lands and the Vos Island, one of
> them they have to give up.
I think you should let them keep their Brecht holdings – they will need
those as a base to amass the resources they need to even attempt taming
the island domain of their dreams. However, if clearing the wilderness is
their main goal, then their Brecht holdings should be pretty much a
sideshow. Let them expand them slightly, enough that they are a
reasonable source of gold for the troops and ships and supplies they will
need to carve their mark on the wilds, but then make them just background
for the main event, which will pretty much be a standard adventure
campaign of wandering through trackless forests and frozen mountaintops
hunting down and slaying the countless monsters who must inhabit the
island. Also, beware of interference from various groups who may already
live there in secret and wish to prevent any settlement being established
(e.g., elves, dwarves, giants, ice goblins, or the monastery of ancient
scions guarding the sielsegh of Basaia from the Book of Magecraft), or
other competing would-be settler groups.
> Boy did I get the glares on that announcement ( they did work very
> hard to get there holding and where they are now and dont want to give
> them up). I was then informed that there leutennants could run things
> for them. Again I informed my Mob that its not the same and again
> more glares, finnally we reached an agreement, I will research the
> argument and come up with a final rulling, this was acceptable to all.
Carving entirely new provinces out of utter wilderness is a truly
Herculean task; to have any chance of accomplishing it, they must devote
all their energies to it to the exclusion of all else. If they want to be
less ambitious, and just try to establish holdings outside Brechtur in,
say, Rjurik and Khinasi, that could be done without giving up significant
control over what they already have.
Ryan Caveney