Generic Holdings

What`s the qualitative difference between law, guild, and temple holdings?
Aside from realm spells, which is a whole different kettle of fish, two
generate RP and GB income, one generates RP and lets you claim (nee tax)
GB from other holdings.

Law holdings represent government; taxation is traditionally a flat fee
(bridge tolls), or a percentage of your possessions` values, or a
percentage of your income (modernly).

Churches made money in the middle ages by collecting a percentage of
income (the tithe) and by selling knicknacks and relicky bits to tourists.

Guilds made money by buying low and selling high. :slight_smile:

Theres a lot of overlap in those three areas. Certainly the internal mechanics of all of them would be similar, all would have functionaries and clerks to keep track of income and expenses, and administer internal rules, but sometimes the clerks wear holy symbols and sometimes they operate in the name of the king. Sometimes the rules are called scriptureand sometimeslegal codeand sometimesguild law`.

If you think of Talinie or Medoere, what`s the difference between the law
and the temple there? Religious law and secular law are administered by
the same body in a theocracy. The income of both goes into the same pot.
Similar thoughts can apply to Endier, or to Cariele, where the guilders
pretty much run things as they see good for business.

Theres good flavor value in differentiating between guilds and temples and constables, but mechanically it would be interesting to see them combined as just general holdings`.

Youd need to extend the GB collection charts beyond level 10 holding in
a level 10 province`, obviously, up to a 30 or 40 in a 10, if you wanted
to keep the present system mostly intact. With the combination of
holdings, you might need to adjust maintenance to balance again, since
Talinie would suddenly have about 2/3 the number of holdings they used to,
for example. Might be easier to work that into the income chart as less
efficiency at higher levels.

I think you could dispose of the old system entirely. Need to think about
this.

Leave province ranking the same. 0 to 10.

Total possible holdings in the province = provlevel squared. All temples,
guilds, and law holdings come out of this pool. I havent puzzled out sources yet, theyre too disjoint to the system.

Get rid of the notion of province ruler- the one with the highest
holding levels is the one with the most authority. So the Chamberlain in
the Imperial City might have a 10 (old province level) + his law holding +
5 or 10 for good measure, under this method, so maybe 20. Avan, Boeruine,
and Diemed might have 10 or so each, the City is closely contested.

Now you have room to give the Wizard College, many more temples, and
several minor guilds, and maybe old imperial institutions like the
Imperial Court or the Imperial Senate (or whatever) small holdings in the
city, which would have been at best holdings (0) under the original
system. Lots of minor counts, earls, baronets, abbeys, unions and guilds
can now appear on the domain level screen.

Trade routes can be done away with, and the guilders just rule their
guilds up higher. Seems simpler that way.

A temple would just be a holding devoted to a god (obviously), and it
would make money and RP the way it used to. I`d have a separate asset, a
cathedral or something, which would have to be built to cast realm spells,
rather like the rules on fortifying a holding now- the level a temple
holding is cathedralled to (I verbed it) is the level used to cast realm
spells.

Youd probably have to inflate the income table, so not every holding 1 in a province 10 was getting d3 GB/turn like they do now. That kind of ties in with my ideas about province production/surplus, but I need a nap before the Fiesta Bowl so Ill post on that later.

Communication is possible only between equals.
Daniel McSorley- mcsorley@cis.ohio-state.edu


The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.

> If you think of Talinie or Medoere, what`s the difference between the law

and the temple there? Religious law and secular law are administered by
the same body in a theocracy. The income of both goes into the same pot.
Similar thoughts can apply to Endier, or to Cariele, where the guilders
pretty much run things as they see good for business.

Theres good flavor value in differentiating between guilds and temples > and constables, but mechanically it would be interesting to see them > combined as just general holdings`.

I was considering redesigning the domain rules centered around a similiar
holding structure to what already exists, but making the holdings more
abstract (instead of generic). Since temples and guilds, for example, both
collect GB, then both a temple regent and a guild regent both have
“Economic Holdings”. All the economic holdings do is collect GB, but using
the specialized holding mechanic that was discussed here along time ago,
different Economic Holdings can be differentiated, so that one regent may
have a Level 4 Economic (Shipping), another might have Level 4 Economic
(taxation), and another might have an unspecialized level 5 Economic
holding. Unless you specialize, however, economic holdings do nothing else
other than collect GB (and maybe RP – I don`t really have RP in my system
yet).

The other holdings Im considering are Administrative, Magical, Military, and Social holdings (theaters, temples, libraries, etc.). All of these have specialized variants, and because they all have specialized functions, there isnt so much overlap. The idea of the “guild regent” is kinda gone, since a "guilder" is going to have a lot of Economic holding, but hes also going
to need some Social and Administrative holdings as well since he can`t
really run a domain without those functions.

The system isnt ready yet, so I dont have many details on how Im going to go. Im simply suggesting that a series of highly specialized holdings
might be a better way to get rid of some of the annoying overlap than a
system of generic holdings.

> A temple would just be a holding devoted to a god (obviously), and it
> would make money and RP the way it used to. I`d have a separate asset, a

cathedral or something, which would have to be built to cast realm spells,
rather like the rules on fortifying a holding now- the level a temple
holding is cathedralled to (I verbed it) is the level used to cast realm
spells.

The specialized holding concept works just like this, as I use it. Except,
that youre basically sacrificing levels for the "cathedral" effect, rather than "fortifying" it. So a specialized holding is going to be more useful than a non-specialized holding, but its generally going to be lower level
(assuming the same resources are spent in both examples).

-Lord Rahvin


The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.