On Tue, 2002-12-03 at 06:16, daniel mcsorley wrote:
> On Mon, 2 Dec 2002, Peter Lubke wrote:
> > > So Im trying to reconcile 3es free-for-all multiclassing with the 2e
> > > notion that certain classes get regency from certain holdings.
> >
> > Its not a 2e notion - its a BR notion. That`s a huge distinction. It
would be most incorrect to state that “in 2e this happened…” when in
actuality it is nothing of the sort.
I think it was a 2e thing, though. In that version, character concept was
extremely closely tied to class.
Agreed - a matter of style which is not in vogue, but not without it`s
good points.
With free multiclassing, that`s no
longer the case- this gets taken to its extreme in d20 modern, where
classes are made as transparent as possible and the character concept is
what matters.
When, in 2e, they needed to assign regent roles to characters, they did it
by class, but thats not really necessary, and it wasnt completely
well-done in the first place.
Agreed (perhaps). (unless) Do you mean that regents shouldnt have roles?, or that the roles shouldnt be assigned by character class?
The mapping of the (sneaking, trap-finding, back-stabbing rogue) to guild
holdings was so loose that they just went ahead and created a new Guilder
class in the Havens book. The tying of warrior-types to aristocratic
heirarchies of law holdings was similarly poorly defined, and I`m not sure
> it was real-world justifiable in the first place. Most kings were not
> good personal combatants, and the ones that were (Richard the Lionheart)
> are often remembered as poor kings. Those that could do both were rare.
Agreed - although they didn`t tie warrior types to realm/law very well
at all
I know /why/ it was done, to create four types of holdings which
corresponded to the four overall character types, and which could coexist
in one area in a way paralleling the teamwork of adventuring parties.
I`m just not sure it was a good enough reason.
Disagree. I think that it is a good idea to create specialist regents.
If all regents are basically the same, there will be much less give and take, and much less actual diplomacy. Diplomacy will become little more
than a threat-based event, because of the one-winner syndrome. Win/Win
situations become not possible - there`s always going to be a downside
for someone. i.e. Always a winner and a loser in any negotiation.
However, this is more a matter of personal preference/style - a minor
issue on which it`s easy to agree to disagree.
>
> So, in 3e, with prestige type classes, I think we get a chance to break
> that coupling entirely, from adventurer class to domain type.
Agreed, its a good idea. But not that the implementation *needs* prestige classes to work or not though. OTOH, Im not saying you can`t
do it using prestige classes either.
I`m not
> even convinced you should need divine spellcasting to rule a temple-
> however, the presence of miraculous casting in D&D is enough to sway me on
> this point. The head of a temple should be capable of spells if he wants
> RP for the temple. Otherwise he just gets money.
Agreed. I`d go even further and say that the head of a faith/set of
temple holdings need not be a priest to cast realm spells - there are
enough priests within the organization for this already. e.g. The Queen
of England is not a priest, but is the head of the Church of England.
And why not collect RP too - the prestige is only truly useful within
the organization.
I think the prestige/advanced class mechanic provides a good answer here.
Im going to use 4 prestige classes that solve the problem for me, and > > > give a couple of other good features, too. Theyre similar to the d20
modern advanced classes in that their prereqs are rather low- many
characters could go into them after first level in a regular class.
Default: All characters gaing full regency from provinces in their realm.
No RP is gained from any other holding the character controls.
Additionally, by default all actions can only be domain actions- realm
actions, affecting multiple holdings, are available only at prestige
levels.
Daniels solution suffers only one major drawback (and one minor), as it
solves (a), (B), but not © above. (A character which inherits a
domain - other than a realm - may be unprepared to collect regency in an
efficient manner. Of course it could be argued that this would be a poor
choice of heir for the previous regent to make, however it`s a more
> > restrictive choice than previously.
>
> Not much more restrictive. Before, a temple regent had to leave her
> holdings to another blooded cleric for it to be fully utilized.
Actually, that`s untrue. An heir can inherit a bloodline and domain even
if the heir is unblooded. In fact most heirs do inherit the bloodline of
the donor (extinguishing any prior bloodline). A blooded heir has little
advantage over a blooded heir for the purposes of inheriting a domain.
(of course their usefulness as lieutenants is not germane to the
discussion here)
I`d argue that it is very much more restrictive. However, as we both
point out - a judicious selection of candidates for heir avoids the
issue. This is a bit of a fudge though - a requirement for convenience
sake.
[As a side point: I don`t really like the `designated heir` as a
primary/single method of succession. I think the incumbent such have
some say, but except for source networks, the organization itself should
more commonly decide on the `heir`.]
The
prestige class way just requires a slight bit more forethought, that you
should groom a potential heir into one of these classes ahead of time (the
requirement is just blooded scion, not being a regent, so its not hard > to work that far ahead.) In fact, in a good sized temple like the WIT > (for example), youd probably have a bishop every couple of provinces who
had at least one level in the Templar class, for redundancy or ambition`s
> sake.
>
> > In fact (B) is only partially solved as well - characters who wish to
> > add holdings of a different type to their base class may gain no
> > benefit from them.)
>
> They get money, which is often the main reason for going into another type
> of holding. If they want RP, I think they should have to work harder.
Agreed - in principle. And I think this was the issue that the BR
designers were trying to address when they restricted RP collection in
the first place. Game balance and interaction between regents of
different holding types (although not necessarily cooperation or
contention).
The comment that reflects the practical strategy of a BR regent player,
rather than the ideal. Rules which dictate strategy are, IMO, less
desirable than those that allow a more open-ended game, where a
player/regent can determine their own success criteria.
Actually the main type of “holding” that players try to add is a
province (unless they already have some) - which always adds RP under
the original rules (and your proposal if I understand it correctly).
If they do have provinces, they try to add guilds - and trade routes.
(for the GB as you correctly point out)
[for the purpose of argument above - “holding” is defined as any asset
held by a regent that may potentially generate RP.]
>
> > In effect he has created not four but five classes as realm-ruler is
> > given to all by default. It has the elegance of allowing a character to
> > rule any type of domain efficiently regardless of character class.
> >
> > The minor drawback is that he still hasn`t answered the original
question (2) above. Hes just changed the names of the classes > > involved. It could be argued that its a slip-in-under-the-table
argument for collect from all but well make all a little more > > difficult. As such its tainted with the not the intention of BR
argument.
Im not trying to just rename the classes, Im trying to divorce regency
collection from adventuring. So yes, theyre different classes, but a > law-regent isnt much like a fighter at all. Neither is a guilder much
like a rogue, nor does a templar have to be a powerful priest to guide his
flock. Theyre specialized in their administrative field. *sniff* smells like a rose, looks like a rose ---- so you tinkered a little, but didnt change the essential nature of things. Renamed and
modified - how`s that?
Again, though: What`s your answer to point (2) ?
i.e.
How many classes can you collect regency for ? (cumulatively)
The implication is:
“As many base/pre classes as you take”
My solution for 2e: (which of course works for 3e as well - but its > > much simpler as is less likely to appeal to those who like more > > convoluted systems) > > (1.1) Regent classnotcharacter classdetermines RP collection. > > (1.2) There are five(5) regent classes; realm, faith, guild, govern, and > > magic --- similar to what Daniel proposes > > (1.3)Realmregents collect RP for provinces,Guildregents collect > > RP for guilds/trade, etc etc --- Daniels classes have more complex > > collection rules, but are not dissimilar > > (1.4) A regent can have manyregent classes`. There is no cost, no
> > penalty or restriction whatsoever. —
> > (1.5) But, a regent may only collect RP for one of his/her regent
> > classes at his/her choice - but duh! - usually the one that yields the
> > highest RP — this final piece is an answer to (2), as well as (a),
> > (B), and ©
>
> If your realm and governing classes are disjoint, then one cannot gain RP
> from both provinces and law at the same time.
Yes, correct. And this is a huge step forward allowing a much greater
diversity of government types than before. e.g. You can have a ruler of
a realm/province who is little more than a puppet - with the law holder
pulling the strings - although it should be noted that, for any single
province - the province ruler will always have at least as much power
than the law holder. There are many benefits to this.
But, you did this yourself too.
> That was a pretty sizeable
> benefit under the original rules, that anyone who ruled a province got RP
> for it no matter what else they were.
Yes, that was so. All the original play-testers had realms - regardless
of their character class. And, as long as all regents have realms - they
are more or less in the game. As you probably know from actual games,
the first priority of a non-realm regent is to gain a realm. (or ally
temporarily with a realm regent hoping to stab him in the back later and
take his realm)
> I think this was intentional- the
> land and beliefs of people in Cerilia are powerful and simple enough that
> simply lording over them gives you power.
Yes, and how did I change that?
> Drawing power from something
> less substantial, like the beliefs of people in an economic system, or the
> rule of law, or awe towards another entity (a god), or flowing tides of
> mebghail, was more difficult and so available to fewer regents.
A temple, guild, or law holding will always generate less than or
equivalent RP than the province in which it sits, and these holdings
generally have to be built up at great cost. (You dare to insinuate
that the Grand Wizard Zzekhiel is not a match for a puny Vizier?) —
just kidding on the last.
But not fewer regents surely? Isnt it more likely that there would be more non-realm regents than realm regents? While the hearts and minds of the populace of a province can (in their majority) only be given to one regent - they can easily be divided in their loyalties to temples. Also the struggle for economic or magical dominance should be a *struggle*. While all regents seek to have some influence in the interplay of government - a regent controlling a province(4) with a law(4) as well is quite a dictator, which is fine in some cases but should not be seen as the normal` situation IMO.
Also, it looks like a fighter could collect full regency from temples or
sources under this method, and that doesnt sound right to me. He should > have to demonstrate some magical ability. (see comments re: temple/faiths above) But, yes - a fighter/warrior type could control and gain RP from many sources. Such will do him very little good however, as sources themselves arent good for much except casting spells. Consider that a
ranger type however, dedicated to the preservation of wilderness/natural
surrounds/magic potential, might have some interest in the endeavor.
(not that Id suggest its a game winning strategy)
The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.