Undead Legion

Recent discussions of warfare have reminded me fondly of many things I’ve said on the topic before, one of which I’d like to bring up again. The true strength of undead troops is not their morale effects on the battlefield (they never run away, and encourage others to run away sooner), but their immense strategic mobility. They do not tire, eat, sleep, or breathe. This means that they should, at a rough D&D mechanics estimate, move on the strategic scale six times as fast as normal units of their type, since they can double-time 24 hours a day instead of march at single speed for eight hours. Even zombies are faster than human infantry, because they can slowly shuffle without stopping for three times as long per day. They should cost less to move between provinces, because their logistical tail is lighter: they don’t need food, clothing, shelter or medical care, so it needn’t be paid for to bring along. They can cross rivers, lakes, even oceans by simply walking along the bottom. They can actually bridge rivers for the use of other troops, or even dam them, just by linking arms and walking in. You can even move them surreptitiously by shipping them in sealed packing crates, because they have no need or even desire for nutrition, light, air or freedom.

All of these things apply equally well to constructs, so, for example, the magically-powerful and immortal-except-for-battle Sidhelien should have armies composed not of themselves, but instead of golems. It gives them all the same advantages without any need for necromancy.

Ryan

Unless your undead legion is commanded by Intellegent undead I would think that they are limited in movement by the “life burdened” commanders that guide them. In most circumstances undead legions would likely not march any faster than human troops, save for say avoiding forced march penalties etc..

On the contrary, the living commander can be carried in a carriage or palanquin for most of these (except the underwater stuff). Plus, since he pretty much has to be a high-level spellcaster, making his own food, water and air probably isn’t much of a problem. Even so, “march that way as fast as you can, stop when you reach the ocean, and kill anything that tries to stop you” is a fine order to give, and then catch up with later via flight, teleportation, or sea travel (much faster than land travel).

Ryan

While indeed the Undead would follow such an order that leaves the commander of such a force little in the way of situational control. The purpose of a commander is to adjust and react to changes in the tactical/strategic situation and provide direction and guidence to the forces he controls.

Without on the spot “Living” and “awake” guidence the commander of an undead army is assuming a lot risk. Indeed the limit on undead mobility may be found in the requirement of a commander to make frequent “adjustments” to his orders in order to get the best deployment from his mindless troops.

An army of Warforged (Self Aware Constructs)from the Ebberon setting would be the ultimate mobility army. Able to march without end and if commanded by other warforged able to adjust and react to changes in the situation along the way.

My thoughts on the matter anyway…

Two necromancers, one the mentor, the other his faithful appretice (of sufficient level to do the work, but hoping to “inherit” his master’s source holdings) can each operate for 12 hours without difficulty, resting and then catching up to the army either by magical movement or swift animal (living or shadow).

Ok, Ok, I yield the point…grumble grumble…find me a “loyal” necromancers apprentice..grumble grumble..:wink:

Easy fix, keep the enemy’s “living” and “awake” commanders distracted by creating a catastrophe where they are, delaying responce to news of the column of zombies. Summon a fire elemental to wreak havok in the market place of the capital. Spread rumors about things that aren’t happening so the “living” and “awake” commanders go running after wild geese while your mindless zombies march unopposed according to instructions.

Apprentices are very good at being the “living” and “awake” presence, even if their only duty is to read the Message scroll and send the master word of the three paladins, cleric, and their company of knights that has just arrived. More advanced apprentices can take command of a small body of troops and give them new directions.

From the wiki…

The legion of dead is mindless and entirely under the control of the caster. The caster must travel with the army at all times or the spell will be broken and the army will collapse.

I unyield!! (Is that a word??) Since the caster must travel with the army and the legion responds to his/her orders I contend that the Caster must rest (Unless undead himself) and therefore the army moves slower than it could if unburdened by its necromancer. :wink:

From the Wiki…

Undead Legion Special + 8 - 22 3 1 (+ 6) - Fearless (cannot be routed), immune to subdual damage, mustered/maintained by realm spell

While I do not concede giving Undead greater adjustment than being able to force march at will without effect. I do think that a move of 1 is very low and should be adjusted.

An Undead Legion is powered by a realm spell. A necromancer of sufficient level can send a significant number of undead to mindless tasks as Ryan described (“march that way as fast as you can, stop when you reach the ocean, and kill anything that tries to stop you”) without having to draw on the realm spell. As flexible as regular necromancy is, I’m not sure why anyone would use the realm spell, unless they are caster level poor and source rich.

The value of undead depends a lot on how you define ‘mindless’. I’m quite harsh about it…

If your undead will happily march over cliffs, through fires, into a deep river (and be swept away), ignore a raging bear tearing them apart (since they were ordered to ‘march towards the mountain’ not to attack the bear) then they need constant attention or they effectively self destruct - asimovs 3rd law need not exist in the undead - indeed if you give them some slim intelligence they might crave destruction…

Your necromancer therefore can of course be carried by the undead / pulled in a coach etc, although he will stand out wonderfully by doing so, but if the undead are out of earshot (zombie earshot that is) then they cannot control the undead to protect them from hazards.

Even a ditch could damage a number of zombies who fall in it, break limbs, etc and are trampled by those behind, although I’m sure most people don’t make their undead vulnerable to rotting, etc like I do, negative energy could I suppose be considered to prevent such…

You have to give undead int 1-2 just to be able to leave them to walk down roads and the like without risking losing some of them, the apprentice mentioned earlier probably spends his time frantically riding up and down a column herding the undead back onto roads, around boulders, etc. As a result an undead legion should imho be limited to a standard march or double at most unless the apprentice wishes to risk being too tired to safely herd them. Of course if you’ve raised a large number and don’t mind some serious attrition, or have some demonic/etc leader who can command vast numbers easily, then yes, they could be terrifyingly swift.

The trouble with undead therefore is that you need a lot of priests/wizards to herd them, and that such folk are rare, expensive, and vulnerable to many things that the legion they lead is not…

but then I dislike zombies and skeletons, cutting their warcard defense from 7 (what were they supposed to be wearing? Dwarven fullplate) to a more reasonable 2-3 for starters and making them cost 2 RP a unit…

The mindlessness of undead… this provokes some ruminations on spirits. There has always been a spirit world for the Birthright world, although it has long since been at least partially under the sway of the Shadow. Summoning animated whatever, is just summoning a spirit of the right type to direct the thing you are animated. Even mundane things have a spirit. This is what a commune with nature spell is communing with, or when you speak to animals or plants. Rocks have a spirt, trees, rivers, what have you. There are more intelligent and powerful spirits that can inhabit these things and they can follow simple instructions without any initiative of their own (Animate Rope) or basic instructions in a limited context (Animal Messenger). Eventually you can summon spirits that can do much more, up to the most powerful elementals or high level summonings.

So undead could then be animated with spirits of the least initiative or of some moderate initiative but limited problem solving. Children, for example have high initiative and low problem solving, so using a spirit of this kind is like sending a child out to do something, certainly capable of making decisions, but sometimes making very questionable decisions. Better spirits animating undead are like adding hit dice, although at some point (ghouls and such) you get pretty good funtioning undead because they must have high quality spirits for animation.

In my campaign I always wondered about the Legion of Dead realm spell…

When summoning an Undead Legion one should really ask from where those bodies come from. Because sonner or later corpses will dissappear, even sooner if Legion of Undead consists of only humanoid corpses. And caster will have to wait for weeks till all the undead he rised gather to be able to assemble a regiment. And some of those undead will never make it, because they would be destroyed by population (priests, adventures, militias, etc.) and some would be destroyed by natural hazards and misshaps. Add population concern for ethics and moralty, and you’ll understand why casters rarely use this realm spell. So easier would be if caster had one regiment to sacrifice, or enough casualities on the battlefield to assemble an Undead unit. But still comrades of the fallen wouldn’t be happy about this ritual, and dead soldiers had families, etc.

Now, if that spell summoned the undead from the Shadow World, then it would be faster, at least one would not have to wait their gathering, but still some would fail to cross the evanessence. Not to mention that there are all kinds of undead, so how can we know the amount of skeletons, zombies, ghouls, etc. are there.

EDIT: Well two previous posts above popped while I was typing… Srry

I guess I was thinking in the Strategic scale, not the tactical and assumed an undead legion, so i suppose you could do this on a small scale with squads, but then again what good do they do if they walk off a cliff?

As to undead int. the canon is pretty clear that despite whatever force is animating them no longer have a will or intellegence of their own.

“Skeletons are the animated bones of the dead, mindless automatons that obey the orders of their evil masters.”

“Zombies are corpses reanimated through dark and sinister magic.
Because of their utter lack of intelligence, the instructions given to a newly created zombie must be very simple.”

Of course what the D.M. chooses to do with Skel and Zomb int is up to them, but I think “gifting” (If being aware of your state in a rotting corpse is a gift) them with int changes the threat level of such creatures and other more int undead are presented already to fit that bill. IMHO :slight_smile:

You can provide undead with an intelligence insufficient to contemplate itself, or what we might call classic self-awareness. But in this specific case, the spirits you are summoning to inhabit undead are Shadow World spirits, they neither see the body as their natural habitation, nor would they approach the situation from a human view of humanoid corpses.

What this aside on spirit summoning amounts to is that higher level chasters can get a more effective zombie or skeleton than a lower level character, and depending on how much more effective they may cost them as more HD than the standard zombie. If you want to invest a bunch of HD summoning in a spirit to animate an ogre zombie, I don’t see a problem with a high level caster getting a spirit with enough sense not to walk off a cliff. He doesn’t need to be bright enough to flank an opponant, or sneak up on it, or use a missile attack before closing in melee, but I’m OK with not doing something a rat would have the sense not to do.

Not against the basic principle of what you are saying/suggesting here, the only question for me is not could it be done but why do this at all?

The Create Undead necromacy spell (Level 6 Cleric/Level 6 Wizard & Sorc) creates Ghouls, Ghasts, Mummies and Mohrgs which are certainly much more effective for the vile one so inclined to summoning undead to create?

anyway to each his own…:slight_smile:

By the way…

From the AD&D Birthright Rulebook (2nd Edition), in regard to Legion of Dead (Wizard Realm Spell):

He (the wizard) must remain with his undead army or the spell will be broken and the army will collapse.

So no; go there, fight, wait for me, blah blah blah… You have to be with them all the time and direct them.

An 8th level caster, could animate four 8HD ogre zombies if the animation is done in a desecrated area. These could be controlled as well. You need to be 11th level to use create undead to create a ghoul, the weakest of the improved undead, and you need to be able to cast 6th level spells. It would certainly seem that there is a gap between when you are creating powerful zombies (assuming ogre corpses are at hand) and when you can create the more intelligent undead.

An Undead Legion is powered by a realm spell. A necromancer of sufficient level can send a significant number of undead to mindless tasks as Ryan described (“march that way as fast as you can, stop when you reach the ocean, and kill anything that tries to stop you”) without having to draw on the realm spell. As flexible as regular necromancy is, I’m not sure why anyone would use the realm spell, unless they are caster level poor and source rich.

An undead legion composed of zombies and skeletons would be far more effective as a terror tactic against a civilian target than against a proper army. Mindless units are easy to ambush and slow units are easy to harras. Its hard to recruit living units to serve with undead units, and I would imagine that few can do it save the most great, tyrannical powers.

On the other hand, raising zombies or skeletons, sending them deep into enemy territory and releasing them to create more is easy to do and fun for the whole family.

What I typed in my previous post was from OFFICIAL BIRTHRIGHT RULEBOOK…

Wizard cannot give tasks to the undead created by the Legion of Dead Realm Spell if himself is not there to keep them from collapsing and maintaining their negative energy link…

…

Who uses Undead Legion? Regular necromancy spells work much, much better and far, far less expensive.