>Ah, the primordial question: What Birthright Means to Me
I think this topic merits its own thread… and since I have a lot of
comments, I`ll go ahead and put them here. These ideas are about the
domain level of play and what it means to RPGs, BR in particular.
-
My Birthright. I absolutely support tweakers and homebrewers
(both gaming homebrewers and those who make their own beer.) In
fact, I look at published materials as a sort of raw material, or a
kind of rough diamond. Its up to gamers themselves to refine the material and make it their own. Its all well and good to run
adventures “straight out of the box” because lets face it, we dont
all have time to invent our own materials 100% of the time, and
sometimes we just want to game, but it is both our right and pleasure
to take things to the next level and polish them up whenever
possible. It is, however, important to know the original ideas and
their intent before extrapolating. One can do anything one likes in
a homebrew, but if one doesn`t know the original materials well then
extrapolation and elaboration suffers because such processes are only
as good as the raw materials upon which they are based. -
Gaming at Its Best. RPGs came from wargames. Wargames came from
board games. Board games came from bored people who wanted to engage
their minds in some way, often using their personal experience as the
basis for their activities (though sometimes these things were so
abstracted as to make it difficult to really find the original
inspiration.) RPGs are so far the highest form of gaming–beyond
even advanced computer modelling–because they employ intelligence
and creativity in ways that are beyond a set of rules or
instructions. No game ever can incorporate a simple conversation the
way an RPG does. RPGs themselves often backtrack through gaming in
ways that are sometimes “degenerate” IMO. A RPG session that winds
up being little more than one combat encounter after another is a
step backwards. Theres nothing wrong with wargames or boardgames (I like them both) but we should recognize that they are not gaming at its best. Gaming at its best incorporates the kind of interaction
that goes beyond the board, table or sandlot. RPGs are gaming at
their best when they express character in ways beyond stats,
interaction with NPCs mimics political and interpersonal realities
and worlds are created in a nearly palpable sense in the process. (I
like to think they actually do exist somewhere in the fractal/quantum
omniverse–like Tron…) -
Combat Rules are Gaming by Other Means. I
m sure most folks know that von Clausewitz is famous for his dictum that "war is politics by other means." Its not entirely true, or I think hes been rather badly misinterpreted, which served as an excuse for launching wars through the 20th century that killed millions, and Ive read a few
historians who lay those deaths at his door. Regardless of whether
that`s fair or not, we can take a cue from him and state the
dichotomy like this: Combat is role-playing by other means. The best
role-playing avoids actual combat as much as possible, or resolves
battles as a last resort.
Theres a scene in series "Deadwood" that Im very fond of because it
expresses these issues so neatly. It`s a western, but it illustrates
how gaming issues that are expressed in BR are universal. A
messenger/LT of the local Boss (regent) in the series returns to
Deadwood from Yankton, which is a nearby “domain” that has already
been incorporated into the federal government and represents another
domain that is more powerful and influential than that controlled by
the Boss. The LT informs the Boss that several men have been
appointed to oversee the “territory” by Yankton with the backing of
the federal government, and much to his chagrine none of these
appointees are men controlled by the Boss. A second LT suggests
going to Yankton and murdering all the appointees in their beds, but
the first LT notes that that would be playing right into their
hands. What worries Yankton is the possibility that the Boss has
“other ways to move on them.”
Thats an expression of the political level of play. Its what
gaming does at its best, and we find it most effectively at the domain level of play when done properly. Thats not to say there
should be no violence in BR. Of course there should be combat. But
that combat should be the result of carefully orchestrated
competition and an expression that players and NPCs have run out of
other options. If one looks at modern film and literature (and
politics, but lets not go there) violence is employed by those who have run out of other means and methods to affect their personal, political and economic goals. In modern film violence is almost always instigated by villains who have been consistently and effectively countered by the hero(es) of the story. Conversely, when heroes engage in violence it is because theyve been “forced” to by
the political machinations of the villains. Truly powerful people
dont bother with violence. Its not necessary. They can more
easily get what they want without resorting to physical force.
Too often gamers resort to combat too quickly. Combat rules and
fights are all well and good if everyone enjoys themselves, but we
should recognize that it isnt gaming at its best--its a step back
to wargames or even board games in the “evolution” of gaming–and if
were trying to express things at a higher, political level of play like that illustrated by the BR domain level such action shouldnt be
rewarded, or it should be rewarded in a way that makes it clear there
were other means. What it really represents is their PCs acting in a
way that shows the world they have little real, political
power. Violence weakens leaders both materially AND politically, and
gaming at its best (which is what Birthright means to me) should
reflect that dynamic.
Gary