That is why you define the code of conduct in more detail. It shouldn’t just be alignment based it should be more of conduct based and tied into the deity itself - that is the things the deity finds extremely important and core.
Its quite possible to achieve irreconcilable conflicts between very similar ideologies, for example two LG sects, where one holds that good produces the law, and the other holds that law produces the good. They may be terrible enemies (though their conflicts are quite chivalrous). The addition of any other serious ideological componant (Roger Elearum is the founder of our doctrine) can add new things to fight over. Its this commitment to fight over ideology that creates the paladin.
Normal D&D assumes the alignments are all in harmony with co-aligned beings, so that a LG force of X from Y encounters a LG force of A from B and the modifiers and presumtion is that they will combine to oppose a diametrically opposed force. As I have mentioned elsewhere, D&D supposes an alignment-manifest cosmology.
Birthright has some of that, if you structure a game around the encroaching Shadow and the second (or third) Rise of Azrai, then is likely that a LG forces of Haelyn will join forces with NG forces of Erik and LN forces of Avani to combat the new threat.
However, its also quite possible to structure the BR game so that LG forces of Haelyn fight LG forces of Haelyn because one group holds allegience to the Book of Laws as a source of litterally understood truth, the founding principles of what is now called the Orthodox Imperial Temples, and a personal loyalty to its current regent, while the other group prefers other texts, other interpretations, calls itself Impregnable Heart of Haelyn, or Northern Imperial Temple, or what have you, and there is another cult or personality to some other ruler.
As such, you could devise different paladins for each, clerics for each, spell lists, feat lists, skill lists, and on and on.
Further, you could divide temples between aspects of Haelyn, so you have the Courage paladin, the Lawgiver paladin, the Regal paladin, and these have different relationships to the Storm Paladin, the Liberator paladin, and the Crusader paladin of Cuireacen, not to mention every other kind of paladin you can imagine. These may fight with one another when they aren’t fighting external threats.
“Noble and Proud champion of Justice, I fight with you this day against the Celestial Spellords and their impure souls. But do not think I have forgotten our own quarrel, Once these Owls of Lore are put down we will resume our own disputes. May you find victory in battle on this day, though I do emplore you to give mercy, for you fellows of justice can forget what Haelyn teaches of mercy. Look, they approach, onward!”
You don’t have to fetishize every subtle difference in ideology, but the fact that you can, demonstrates that you can have almost unique paladins, influenced by their single teacher, and then diverging as each paladin carves his new path.
Oh, indeed! But that doesn’t answer my question about why people who are defined by their violent moral absolutism seem to be (by the rules) preferentially assigned to mixed alignments (like LG and CE) rather than pure ones (like LN and NE), which would seem more logical to me. I’m honestly confused here. Can anyone help me out?
This is the kind of game I prefer, which fits well with my feeling that the alignment system is not useful to me. However, I would still like to try to understand what it is that people who do like it are thinking.
So, just how many paladins do people think there are, in total, in Cerilia? If there are really this many different kinds, it seems to me that each one is an entirely unique individual (in the sense that, for example, there is one guy, perhaps with an apprentice, who is the paladin of IHH). I just don’t think there are all that many people who are both cut out to be paladins and interested in making all the sacrifices the job entails.
Ah, yes. “Me against my brother; my brother and me against my cousin; my cousin and me against my neighbor; my neighbor and me against the world.”
Ryan
Well, I would say that the extremity of alignment is independent of the actual alignment.
If you see the alignment as a circle (rather than as the usual square), with distance from the centre representing the strength of views, you can see that a LE and CG character can actually be quite similar if they don’t feel very strongly about their beliefs (i.e. are weak willed, lack introspection, are young, etc) despite being 180 degrees apart in belief terms while the circumference is full of extreme views regardless of the specific position on the circumference and two people of the same alignment could in fact be further apart in belief than two of differing alignments. I agree theoretically with some things that various monomaniacs think - but the extremes to which they take their viewpoint bothers me more than people who quietly but passionately disagree with me…
So someone who believes strongly in law or good is no more or less likely to be extreme in their views than someone who believes strongly in both imho. Does a racist hate one race less because he also hates another? Similarly many of the extremists in public life are extreme about everything they come across be it trade practices, unconventional sexuality, ‘immoral advertising’, etc, etc.
Not incidentally that I believe that a paladin should be any more or less extreme than a priest, indeed I prefer to see them as exemplars or paragons rather than as demagogues. Be a hero that others see, admire, and imitate rather than a martinet that demands unbending adherence to a code most find impossible to adhere to.
I like the idea of mixed class fighter-priest for paladin, or fighter-druid for ranger, under 3e multiclassing removes a lot of the need for the hybrids. I’d deally want some way to swap spells for granted powers though…
I put up a little piece on this subject on the wiki under “Honor paradox”. It addresses the literary subject so common where the character is torn between two competing virtues, and draws power and limitations from each. Two codes (and Chivalry has more than several competing virtues) provides for good story potential . Since D&D borrowed (sometimes without thinking things through) from literature heavily, this trope worked its way into the game, and we seem to have it for good. I agree that one of the “pure” alignments Lawful Neutral, for example, would represent a more extreme lawful character than one who tempers his lawfulness with compasion and mercy, or comprimises it with cruelty and hatred. But without the complication of honor paradoxes, its a less interesting character unless you can introduce other values to complicate his life.
So, just how many paladins do people think there are, in total, in Cerilia? If there are really this many different kinds, it seems to me that each one is an entirely unique individual (in the sense that, for example, there is one guy, perhaps with an apprentice, who is the paladin of IHH). I just don’t think there are all that many people who are both cut out to be paladins and interested in making all the sacrifices the job entails.
One the one hand, you can run each paladin as a unique character, and I think for the paladin class, this is probabaly the way to go, there are few, and each should struggle to find his own path. But my main point was that not every paladin has to find a place between the two points of Lancelot and Galahad.
When I was playing 3.0, I started using templates to solve some of these kinds of problems. I turned Paladin into a template that allowed you to purchase paladin feats (all the paladin type special abilities with proper pre-reqs) as a fighter/cleric. I’d be happy with Paladin as a strait class or as a template, depending on what the player needed.
On the question of how many? I’ll say that the crazy paladin requirements in 2e were again based on literary tradition. The paladin had to be worthy to at least see the grail (only three of Arthur’s knights could behold it) if not actually obtain the grail (only one was good enough). Since paladins are just fighter/clerics rolled up into one class, I don’t see (barring a grail quest) why they should not be as common or as possible as a fighter/cleric.
I’m gonna tempt the math fates and give a math answer to this question and risk getting hit with a salmon by Ryan. We have two axies (or is it axeseses), good-evil and law-chaos. One can, as you propose be just as far in linear distance from the true neutral position as LG as a person who is NG, but the NG person has put all of their distance in one direction, Good. But the LG person has put some distance in becoming lawful and some distance in becoming good. So the total distance in any direction from either one of the axiescies is less than if I put all of my ideological eggs in one basket.
Imagine that I go 2.83 units in the Neutral good direction and you go 2.83 units in the Lawful Good direction. I rank as a 2.83 Good guy, and you rank a 2.0 good guy. And the fact that your lawful is relevenat only to people who care about such things, and clearly, I don’t.
But what if being both lawful and good imposes comprimises on both your lawfulness and your goodness? I will draw the following analogy. I am Reggie and you are Archie. I date only Veronica. You alternate between Betty and Veronica. You invest 2 nights a week to Betty and 2 night to Veronica. I invest 4 nights in Veronica. You are still rated 2 and 2, and you still rate a 2.83 in Betty and Veronica, but I rate a 4 in Veronica. Because much more obviously than Lawful and Good, I can’t date both Betty on Vernonica at the same time. Both because this is a family friendly site, but also because anyone familiar with Lore will tell you, you end up with stars and birds circling your head if you have a date with both Betty and Vernoica at the same time. Then you have to loan Jughead some money and go out for sandwiches at Pop’s.
grin It’s good to know my contributions are appreciated.
sigh One axis, many axes.
Yes, if the total distance from the center is constant. Andrew has suggested a system in which both direction and distance are variable, so that a Law 1, Good 1 person and a Chaos 1, Evil 1 person are actually closer in raw distance to each other than either is to a Law 10, Good 10 person. Certainly a possible model, but I’m not sure I think it’s a very useful one, ideologically speaking.
Yes, this is what I had in mind. If you are both lawful and good, you have to make more complicated decisions more often than if you’re just lawful or just good. While I agree that this is good roleplaying fodder, paladins as a stereotype have always struck me as the sort of people who picked that job because they don’t have a very complicated moral compass, and like having all ethical choices be very stark and therefore quite easy to decide.
This is the view I have come to as well. Since I have also enthusiastically adopted the “no more than half total levels from spellcasting classes” rule, IMC all priests are fighter/clerics or aristocract/clerics or cleric/experts, etc., so there is no longer any game-mechanical distinction between priest and paladin (unless you stretch it to consider Ftr 4 / Clr 4 vs. Ftr 6 / Clr 2).
Ryan
I find it very useful. If the strength of your belief is just 1 or 2, you will frequently act in a manner contrary to your overall alignment - if its 10 almost never.
So a merchant can be lawful good (3, 2) and still stiff the PC’s, smuggle a few goods, etc - nothing major but enough to make life a little easier. A merchant with (10, 8) on the other hand not only wouldn’t break the law like that, he probably gives to orphans and feeds starving puppies.
People in the centre probably feel intimidated by the ‘extreme, unpragmatic / unworldy’ views of people on the circumference - and people on the circumference likely feel that those in the centre lack direction and moral assurity…
Youth probably also has an impact.
I would note that to be LG, NG, and CG can all be equally good - the L/N/C should only impact the interest in self or community - not good or evil. It is perfectly possible to be as passionate about 2 things as 1 (i.e. do you love your children? did you stop loving #1 as much b/c #2 came along?
Hmm, read the Deeds of Paksenarrion for a more complex paladin…
Picking the role to me means that they have a very extreme view (i.e. close to the circumference), not that they favour lack of thought about their religion and morals. Someone with a strong moral centre is very likely to not only focus on the dichotomy between good and evil but also between self and community - to me neutrality indicates lack of resolve or opinion, neither of which is ever lacking in those fervent in their religion.
Should I pass this along to Eleanor of Aquitaine and Henry II? ![]()
And why did no one prefer Geoffrey?
Except that NG people don’t worry much about self or community: they worry only about good and evil. LG and CG people have to worry about both self/community and good/evil, which leaves them less time and energy to be focused on good/evil, and more opportunity to find themselves in situations where they two ideals conflict. People who are neutral on one axis have only one ideal to worry about, so they never have such conflicts, which strikes me as more akin to the way paladins are generally described.
Paks is the only D&D-ish paladin I’ve ever heard of who I didn’t utterly loathe. =) She has paladin powers, but a mind-set utterly unlike anything ever presented in D&D about paladins. Lois McMaster Bujold’s “Paladin of Souls” is about a god’s chosen champion, but that god, his religion, and his champion are nothing remotely like the Gygaxian paladin’s trappings, so I find it much more appealing.
In my experience, those two things seem generally to go hand-in-hand – but the appearance of that topic means this part of the thread should now stop before the flaming begins. =)
I don’t think that’s true; I generally think it is more usual to be extremely passionate about some things and indifferent to others, rather than passionate about everything. Which means, that in your case at least, I have my answer. You think the system as-is accurately reflects what you want to model, so you’d like to keep it; I think it’s inaccurate, so I want to change it. There’s not a great deal left to say, AFAIAC. Anyone else care to comment? How much more common is Andrew’s belief than mine?
What about people who actively choose to seek balance? Do you think that true neutral, as druids used to be required to be, are just people who lack ethical opinions?
Ryan
A couple of good articles on the WotC site concerning alignments:
http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/sg/20050318a
And the really good one on lawful and chaotic:
<snip - text retained in paladin thread>
Law and Chaos
Hmm, I clearly have a fundamental disagreement over the meaning of law and chaos to WOTC… When looking at human nature I fail to see the dichotomy in human nature and philosophy that they clearly do, to me the axis should be more community/self than law/chaos since that has a greater bearing on behaviour - although that may simply be a modern viewpoint. so to me communisim clocks in at Lawful evil (huge community focus, deeply oppressive methods to achieve it), classic liberalism aims for chaotic good (high emphasis on personal freedom, the state should serve the individual, lots of highfalutin talk about permissible methods) comes in as chaotic good. Classic labour movements might be lawful good (the state must cherish and protect the weak and aim to rebalance power throughout society) while various barbarian societies come in as chaotic evil (the state IS the individual, might makes right and victory proves righteousness morality)
Neutrality and pure good
Hmm, I don’t see people as actively thinking about their alignment all that much. A good person doesn’t think ‘I am good so I will think about good things’, they just do them… So to me NG doesn’t mean more or less good than LG, although each would clearly think themselves better - as the LG person likely sees the Law as in itself a good thing, and vice versa. Neutral good is therefore pure good, just good that doesn’t happen to tend towards law or chaos as well.
As you can see from my alignment as a circle system, true neutral is a lack of strong beliefs in my system rather than a strong belief in balance, etc. So I wold leave true neutral to animals, very dim or weak willed folk, very self absorbed folk, etc.
I never really ‘got’ Mr Gygax’s view of true neutral - I couldn’t think of any historic group who actively strove to maintain balance between law and chaos, good and evil, and could not see them surviving if they did. I always assumed he was trying to figure out what beliefs a True Neutral could have and settled for balance as the only one that had any moral conviction. I would put his true neutral ‘maintaining the balance’ ethos as strong Law with the underlying moral theory that the community needs a mixture of types to gain long term strength varying alignment to LG or LE depending on the methods used to maintain balance…
but then by my system the highpriest of Ishtar was strongly lawful evil and the pre-cataclysm Krynn hugely imbalanced towards evil…
The comments by AndrewTall are very interesting, and I’ll offer my thoughts in the same format.
<snip by AndrewTall - text in paladin thread>
Law and Chaos
My own thinking here is to reject any ideology that is modern (such as classical liberalism) for ancient, medieval, or fantastic ideologies. As such, I’m ready to turn the normal thinking about Manicheanism on its side, and ignore the good-evil axis for the order-chaos axis, and describe social entities as lawful and Azrai as the primeval force of chaos. Confusion, corruption, illusion, trickery, deception, the Seeming, and such things are of chaos, while people getting along and following cultures and patterns, no matter how community or individually based, are all lawful. Basically lawful means people, and chaos means primeval forces.
Neutrality and Pure Good
D&D’s system is, as I say, Manichean. There is a good force, and a bad force, and the neutral guy says, I’ll take both please. The good fellow says, I am for for the good and the light and that is my soul, and matter is corruption and I reject my body and go out into the wilderness and deny my body its pleasures. I am celibate, mortify the flesh, fast, and wear a hairshirt. The evil guy says, I love my body and its pleasures, and care nothing for my soul. (the body-soul dualism is only one kind of Manichean possibility, but its concrete, so I’ll run with it) I do what I want to satisfy my body and enjoy material pleasures, and if that makes me jealous, perverse, greedy, and I steal and lie to enjoy pleasures, then so what? As long as I am happy. You can certainly detect a strong Manichean impulse in Christianity, although XP posits that God is more powerful, and ultimately victorious, while a hard core Manichean sees good and evil as perpetually struggling forces of co-equal strength. The neutral person then, rejects either/or and says body and soul, I want both and I revere both. I want to behold the light and preserve my soul, but I want to seek pleasures and satisfy my body when it does not harm others. Both are necessary forces and both must be respected, for without death, how could we afford to bring new life into the world, &c, &c. The Norse produce some good neutral gods in this tradition, figures from the Aesir or Jontun who could cooperate with both, and were not at perpetual odds. Often they were semi-outcasts from their own kind who had allies on both sides. That’s another neutral position.
I see your point, but disagree on practical grounds as playing in the world then requires a detailed knowledge of the medieval world and more importantly the medieval mindset. Most players will not have your skill in that area.
This is particularly key for me as I use alignment as a tool to describe likely behaviour, modern systems are more likely to be correctly interpreted than medieval ones by most players making it more appropriate to provide information that they can use be referring to it in a mode they can comprehend. The 3e system of spells and the like needs to be tweaked in my system but that’s fairly easy.
I do however try to use medieval morals, etc to build legal systems etc in the world. PC’s may well disagree with the laws then, and see them as wrong, but then changing the world is their job…
If that means that the high priest of Avani is evil in my alignment system for encouraging her jihadi to burn the infidel barbarians, claim the lands as ours and bring their children back in chains to be raised as servants to the one true faith then that’s a sacrifice I’ll have to make - I can explain why the church thinks that the actions are acceptable, but see no reason to say ‘and by the way you need to think of them as good’ because the medieval view would support the actions.
<snip, text retained in paladin thread>
I see your point, but disagree on practical grounds as playing in the world then requires a detailed knowledge of the medieval world and more importantly the medieval mindset. Most players will not have your skill in that area.
I consider ideology to be part of the setting, not part of the character. Its the DM’s responsibility, not the players. I wouldn’t tell the players the jihadi priest of Avani is any alignment. I would describe both his behavior and the reactions of others. Since I would regard medieval-normative behavior as normal, the reactions of others would to regard this as fine behavior. Here I think of the way any author describes their characters, what they say about themselves, what others say about them, and leave what the author says to any post-game commentary. Players can regard them as good, bad, or ugly as they please. Once the world gets described in some detail, after many game sessions, then its easy for players to predict what goes on here.
I think the essence of role playing is not to go about as a barbarian in the modern world, but to 1) adopt the persona of a barbarian in a barbarian age, or 2) play yourself as a barbarian in a barbarian age. Playing yourself in the modern world with barbarian costume and the name Hruk the Bloody, doesn’t interest me at all. If I create a coherent world, people will need some introduction to the place, but will begin to catch on to its values and norms before too long.
Agreed, my point was not about the attitudes of the character, but rather the underlying definition of alignment. A handout indicating the public view of a NPC (i.e. this is Gramma Vearl, the village priest you have known since childhood) should I feel contain alignment - not necessarily the NPC’s true alignment but the one that the character would believe correct. Similarly magic that detects alignment gives the player information about the NPC. As such when I say to a PC ‘chaotic neutral’ they should expect the NPC to consider themselves and their needs paramount, be ambivalent about torture and other ‘evil’ methods, etc - the alignment linked by irdeggman would indicate instead that the NPC is inconsistent, lacks of planning and preparedness, etc - a very different thing. It’s how you view the axis on the alignment chart. What WOTC evidently sees as chaotic I would see as lack of consistency - indicating only a weak inclination to any alignment - In my circle chart, an alignment close to the centre rather than on the extreme right. I do feel however that it is important that the alignment definition of good reflects modern morality - to do otherwise invites confusion in my mind.
In terms of roleplaying I fully agree that its more fun to act in character, if harder for some newbie’s initially. However adding a few modern touches to the ‘medieval’ attitudes is fine in my view, so although most soldiers will be male in my games (they are stronger and more expendable) women are legally equal, slavery is considered wrong, society is slightly more fluid for ‘special people’, the church is not quite as dominant, speech is more free - if subject to consequence, etc. I also tend not to discuss infant mortality, the general grime, endemic grinding poverty, etc, etc.
Apart from anything else having played with a number of younger players, some much younger, I see a game as potentially a valuable teaching tool - where else can you explore moral issues and conundrums so easily and well? As a means of teaching about different viewpoints and cultures, history, etc D&D is unmatched in my view - a game must be fun, but it can so easily be educational as well.
A handout indicating the public view of a NPC (i.e. this is Gramma Vearl, the village priest you have known since childhood) should I feel contain alignment - not necessarily the NPC’s true alignment but the one that the character would believe correct.
This is a different problem. In this case I don’t reveal alignments as a shorthand for players because the definition of alignments are ao varied between players that I don’t consider this reliable, which is essential in a shorthand. When you compound questions of how good is someone before you call them good, I end up with such ontological questions that I’d rather describe someone’s reputation than to lable their alignment.
:rolleyes:
Originally Posted by MatanThunder
I consider ideology to be part of the setting, not part of the character. Its the DM’s responsibility, not the players. I wouldn’t tell the players the jihadi priest of Avani is any alignment.
No the alignment is part of the PC and no you as DM don’t have the right to tell the players about how to percieve good and evil (and by extension control their actions as DM). The players play the PC, and the DM paints the setting.
The Jihadi priest would be desinctly evil, and if the PC didn’t live up to their alignment then their alignment (as DM you can do this) would begin to shift towards how they were acting. But individual actions are not limited by DM input…the players should be allowed to play their PC’s…not the DM…
Later
![]()
<snip by AndrewTall: text retained in paladin thread>
I would abandon alignment completely before conforming to the alignment descriptions that conflicted even slightly with the setting description (which is always).
![]()
But do you stand by your quasi statement that it is in the province of the DM to control the alignment concerns of your PC’s…or do they retain free will to play alignment as they see it???
Later
![]()