----- Original Message -----
From: “Lord Shade” <lordshade@SOFTHOME.NET>
Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2003 7:51 PM
> Shouldn`t this be counted in domain maintenance?
I do put the cost on the maintenance section of my domain form.
And a second question - what do temples get for spending half their income
on services? At least armies have a use in domain play; you can use them
to
attack or defend, and if you have no enemies, you can disband all armies
and save some cash. In your game what does a temple get for spending 50%
of
his income on “armies” of people as you put it? (or lose for not having
it)
In England, where the best records of population survive, one person in
seventy was a member of the clergy, and they lived better than the peasants
who paid for their existance. The lowest ordained person is most probably
compatable to a scribe in terms of income (3 sp/day) it would take 30
laborers to support him through tithes. Temples have other costs besides
simply manpower, and while some temple contributors tithe more than the
laborer, some clerics are given food, materials, housing, and pay greater
than the lowest ordained member of the temple. So if 70 people are served
by one cleric, and roughly half of their tithes can be explained by the
maintenance of clergy, where does the other half go? Well some to other
costs of the temple, but also most of that to the temple headquarters to
advance the temple as a whole from central direction on high.
Consider:
Avanil has 167,000 residents. It is defended by 25 units, or 25x200 hit
dice of military power. That`s at most 5000 soldiers, though I would put
the number closer to 4000. Of course Avanil could raise more defenders if
needed (though not by much using historical limits). The temples in the
realm must maintain 2386 clergy, who cost about as much as the soldiers do
in basic maintenance. Of course the clergy dwell and perform their labors
in less humble surroundings, and these temples themselves must be
maintained.
The local bishop was typlically less well off than the lord of the same
region who had a similar amount of authority and regional significance.
Much less of the wealth of the church worked its way up from the operations
of the church than the local lords collected from taxation. In part this is
because taxes were collected at various levels (local lords, higher lords,
the soveriegn) while nearly all church income was local and a proportion
sent up.
The church gets a close and intimate connection with the people, provinding
education, meaning, ritual, and preaching giving the tempels unmatched
ideological power over the people. One of the benefits of this belief
structure is the ability to cast realm spells, something no other social
power can do. Such magic is located at the temple, not at the market,
fortress, or courthouse. The temple also gets free agitate actions every
season. As this mechanism demonstrates, the people will side with the
temple in any conflict with another regent.
> True, but how often do these temples make magic items? I am not trying to
> rebut your points, I am just trying to get a clearer understanding of how
> this works over time. I`d think if you are sinking 10gb every season into
making flaming swords, pretty soon they will be quite plentiful. btw, what
benefit do you get from building lavish constructs? Or is it just gold
thrown down the drain?
Last point first, no lavish constructs, no one knows who you are. Without
cathedrals, there is no ceremony, no ritual, and people cling to local
religion. The same thing is true for all monumental building, whether its
corporate or statist. This is the theory underlying court costs and
diplomacy bonuses. Its also why as temple holdings grow, you don`t just
increase the number of shrines you see in 0-level holdings. 30 such shrines
are not as effective as the assortment of temples, grand temples, and great
cathedrals.
I think 90% of all magic items are created by temples. Wizards need to be
blooded. Clerics dont. Most magic created are spell storage devices, be they potions, runes, or tattoos. A smaller number may be wand-like. Temples of Haelyn might have a "wand of cure light wounds" which is in fact a sword wielded by a long dead paladin hero, known for his laying on of hands and healing of the common people. The revered healing powers of the champion are now said to be vested in his relic sword. The clerics touch you with the sword, speak the heros name and the healing takes place.
Permenant magic items must be rare because characters of higher level are
rare in BR.
> Ok, what are your rules for building trade routes? I have found this to be
> a big problem in PBeM.
There are trade centers in each of the named regions (Heartlands, Taelshore,
Western Basin, &c). Based on roads, rivers, and established routes, it
costs a certain amount to link a holding to a trade center. The system is
based on place theory, which explains how things like markets express
themselves geographically.
Kenneth Gauck
kgauck@mchsi.com
The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.