On Tue, 22 Apr 2003, Adam Theo wrote:
> I`m thinking of changing the BR world a good bit by making elves
mostly druids, rangers, and bards when it comes to spell-casting.
Wizards still exist, but are only those few elves who are very
studious and spend more time with books than out among nature. The
Elven favored class will be Bard to represent most elves dabbling in
lots of things, including magic, song, and dance. Druids will be the
elite healers and magical defenders, while rangers are the elite
scouts and martial defenders.
I think this is a really good idea.
I figured this fit with the elven magic as it is described in the
books, and with the elven view towards magic and nature, than arcane
wizards and sorcerers.
Most definitely, yes!
My only concern is that I still like the thought that elves prefer the
sorcerer and bardic style of spontaneous casting rather than
memorizing like a wizard or druid. Any ideas on how to convert the
druid class to cast spontaneously like a sorcerer?
You could just say they do and leave it at that! I think any resulting
balance worries could be solved simply by changing the animal
transformation ability into just another spell, and perhaps dropping the
hit die from a d8 to a d6. Kenneth`s suggestion of making everyone
channelers is also a fine way to go.
IMC, the line I draw is that casters of true magic (dragons, giants, elves
and blooded members of other species) dont need to memorize, regardless of class (whether wizards, sorcerers, priests, bards or whatever), but casters of lesser magic (unblooded non-elf/dragon/giants) do need to memorize, again regardless of class. Yes, it could be argued that this makes elves more powerful in yet another way, but Im cool with that –
since Id never run a campaign with both elves and non-elves in the same party, Im really not that concerned about balancing them against the
other races. OTOH, since it also means Ive dropped memorization from wizards and blooded priests, Ive made all the other races stronger, too.
The distinction I am inclined to make between wizard and sorcerer is not
spontaneity of casting, but rather degree of specialization – sorcerers
know many fewer spells, but they are better at them as well as cast them
more often. Either that or scrap sorcerers entirely.
> perhaps take the Sorcerer spell per day and spells known, but allow
> elven druids to change their spells known once a month (at a night of
> a full moon),
I think fewer spells per day but greater variety would be a better fit.
My primary objection to treating the Sidhelien as sorcerers has always
been that I think there should be no limit on what they know how to do.
They might not always be as powerful as the humans, but at least they
ought to be more versatile.
> That way if the elf knows what they are going to be facing in the
> following month, they can change their known spells out,
Requiring prior planning a whole month in advance I think really goes
against the Sidhelien culture. Having them be slow to decide to act is
good, but having them unable swiftly to change their minds is bad.
> The rjurik “druids” will actually just be clerics of a nature god
> (Erik), with some minor changes to enhance that.
This I`ve always supported.
Ryan Caveney
The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.