Chap 1 Rev

I told you that I’d try to have the Chap 1 rev out for discussion this week and here it is.

This is a zipped Word doc.

Hee is the pdf version.

Note that both have no graphics at this time.

Originally posted by irdeggman@Mar 2 2004, 10:35 PM
I told you that I’d try to have the Chap 1 rev out for discussion this week and here it is.

COOL! More new and revised stuff!

I Looking through it quickly, these are the items it occurs to me to comment on (and some of them really should be taken more as comments then pointing out something that needs to be changed):
[ul][li] I find it odd that the human can only spend the per level bonus skill point on regional background skills. The 4 points gained at first level makes sense since they ideally grew up in that culture. After that I would assume that the extra point just reflects human versatility and it wouldn’t strictly have to be spent on one of the skills emphasized in the culture they grew up in.[/li][li] Should the noble class really have the same Base Attack Bonus as a Fighter? I suppose this is based off of the style of changes that were made to the 3.5 ranger, but it still seems odd to me. I see a noble being at least as skilled at combat as a cleric or rogue but not more unless they actually multi-class into a combatabt class such as fighter. Especially given the number and nature of their special abilities, which should be really useful in many birthright campaigns.[/li][li] Looking at the mount availability table (1-12) I noticed that heavy warhorses are only available in Anuire and light warhorses are typically restricted to Anuire, Khinasi and the Elves. Yet, the Rjurik, Brecht and Vos can all field cavalry of light or medium weight. That must be really poorly trained cavalry or REALLY expensive. I expect that this is actually a oddity that has been preserved from the original material rather than a deliberate oversight, but couldn’t resist commenting on it.[/li][li] On a similar note, I noticed that the scimitar is listed as the common weapon for elite Brecht warriors (table 1-1) despite the fact that it is only readily available to the Khinasi. Of course, I thought it was kind of odd that the elite weapon was scimitar rather than rapier, but I had assumed that was something ‘suggested’ in Havens of the Great Bay (which I’ve only skimmed since we’ve never played in that region).[/li][/ul]
As always YMMV…and great job so far! Thanks for all the work.

– Blair Monroe

Might want to add a direct link in case any mailing list people want to see and download this.

http://www.birthright.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2317

Just pointing an errata

  • In page 14, Table 1-5 New Skills, marks Lead skill as cross-class skill for Barbarians. The skill text in the same page says “This skill can be used untrained, and is considered a class skill for Barbarians, Clerics, Fighters, Paladins and any class for which Perform is a class skill (including Aristocrats, Bards, and Rogues).”

Comments:

  • Profession skills: as they are encouraged in Birthright, I will suggest to include Profesion (soldier) and/or Profession (Mercenay) for the Fighter class. For them any Profession Skill is treated as a cross-class.
  • Elves: The designers of the 3.5 Ed suggest in the DMG that the +2 Strenght bonus is a greater boon that any other, so they weight it with a -2 both in Charisma AND Intelligence for Half-orks. So a -2 in Strenght would result in a net +2 in the other abilities. So I suggest it would be more adecuate the following modifiers: -2 Strenght, +2 Dexterity, -2 Constitution, +2 Intelligence, +2 Charisma. That would also make sense as the elves are great arcanists (who bases his magic in the Intelligence and Charisma).

Doubts:
Er.. English is not my born language, but how does transform the resistance to bludgeoning damage from the previous version to the 5/piercing and slashing from the present? Bludgeoning isn’t refered to concusion damage, as caused with maces and flails?

Thanks

Originally posted by JanGunterssen@Mar 3 2004, 08:10 PM
[b] Doubts:
Er.. English is not my born language, but how does transform the resistance to bludgeoning damage from the previous version to the 5/piercing and slashing from the present? Bludgeoning isn’t refered to concusion damage, as caused with maces and flails?

Thanks [/b]

In the original (i.e., 2nd ed material) blugeoning refered to a type of weapon. DR always refers to weapon damage and to no other kind. DR lists the things that bypass the DR after the slash so for DR 5/slashing or piercing, any slashing or piercing weapon would bypass the DR.

To make it more simple, Damage Reduction has the following parts:

×/[any clause]
|…|__ Whatever damages the creature without any reduction
|__ The ammount of reduction applied to the damage

Possible clauses include:[ul][li]bludgeoning[/li][li]piercing[/li][li]slashing[/li][li]chaotic[/li][li]evil[/li][li]good[/li][li]lawful[/li][li]silver[/li][li]cold iron[/li][li]- (this damage reduction always applies)[/li][/ul]Furthermore, there can be two or more clauses, combined either with “and” or “or”.

Now that I think of it, it would be interesting to say that this DR also applies on [Force] effects, since they are based on the same logic… Oh well, it will make a fun house rules, that it will…

My own concern goes to the Black Strike Style (if my memory plays me no tricks, that’s the name), now that Two-Weapon Defence, Improved Two-Weapon Defence, and Greater Two-Weapon Defence are out: why care for a +2 dodge bonus when you can get a +2 shield bonus? In any case, A little care on that matter is my suggestion, as well as a little change when it comes to the main-gauche: as a full-basket hilted dagger, would it not be better to say it grants a +2 bonus on attack rolls to avoid being disarmed?

I was just re-reading things in this revision again and a couple of things to ask came to mind.

The first, I was wondering if I could be directed to any discussion on what the Magician class should be like vs. a user of true magic. I was thinking about it and while I like the magician class (and its spell list)as presented, when I look back over the class in the original rulebook it seems like it really isn’t quite what it was as its scope seems to have been both widened considerably and narrowed in other regards.

I certainly don’t want to start another ‘war’ over this so I would be happy to go read old threads discussing the topic before saying anything more.

The other question I had is related to this one. If one opts to use the classes as presented in the BRCS, are there any recommendations for dealing with characters like Rogr Algondier in Ilien? IIRC he is portrayed as having been the unblooded apprentice to the previous Count of Ilien, who was a blooded wizard of reasonably high level. Upon the death of his master, Rogr became Count and received the previous regent’s bloodline. Previously this effectively meant that he could now cast spells of higher than 2nd level and that was that. Now it seems like he would be stuck with being a multi-class Magician/Wizard and having to ‘redo’ the first several levels. Just curious if any thought on how to deal with this type of situation had been discussed and what the designers suggestions for dealing with it would be.

— Blair Monroe

That’s why I have forgone the standard spell system and use a home-brewed Sovereign-Stone spell system, but that is another case…

A suggestion would be that magicians who receive RP can learn to cast spells as wizards, since they learn and work in - almost - the same way, but this could be problematic… Let us see what the people here have to say.

Originally posted by JanGunterssen@Mar 4 2004, 02:10 AM
[b]Doubts:
Er.. English is not my born language, but how does transform the resistance to bludgeoning damage from the previous version to the 5/piercing and slashing from the present? Bludgeoning isn’t refered to concusion damage, as caused with maces and flails?

[/b]

Not certain where you are confused at.

Others have already mentioned that the first part of the DR code indicates the amount of damage ignored and the second part is what type of attack or attacks that will ignore the damage reduction, thus doing full damage.

It also seemed like you could be confusing bludgeoning damage with subdual or nonlethal damage. Bludgeoning describes the way an attack harms its opponent. In 3/3.5 a weapon doing bludgeoning damage is often doing lethal damage straight to the target’s hit points. It is not automatically subdual or nonlethal damage. A mace or flail does lethal damage by way of bludgeoning your target to death. The damage inflicted is no less lethal than the damage a sword would do.

Some bludgeoning attacks such as unarmed attacks and saps are specifically meant to do temporary damage or to knock someone out. In those cases, they are marked in the Player Handbook as inflicting nonlethal or subdual damage rather than hit point damage, but it is still bludgeoning damage.

IIRC, when you apply DR it doesn’t matter if the damage is subdual or hit point damage…only the method in which the damage was inflicted. So punching a Cerilian dwarf (with DR 5/slashing and piercing) with your bare fist or wearing a normal gauntlet (both are bludgeoning attacks) would require you to do more than 5 points of damage to actually hurt the dwarf. It doesn’t matter if it was nonlethal/subdual damage or not. On the other hand :wink: , if you punch the dwarf while wearing a spiked gauntlet (a lethal piercing attack) you are going to have an annoyed dwarf because all of the damage you roll will be applied to his hit points without any being subtracted for the Damage Reduction.

Originally posted by RaspK_FOG@Mar 4 2004, 02:55 AM

My own concern goes to the Black Strike Style (if my memory plays me no tricks, that’s the name), now that Two-Weapon Defence, Improved Two-Weapon Defence, and Greater Two-Weapon Defence are out: why care for a +2 dodge bonus when you can get a +2 shield bonus? In any case, A little care on that matter is my suggestion, as well as a little change when it comes to the main-gauche: as a full-basket hilted dagger, would it not be better to say it grants a +2 bonus on attack rolls to avoid being disarmed?

Hmmm… I just noticed that Black Strike is no longer listed as a feat in the recently posted version of the chapter.

Given that I was going to pick one of the various duelist or swachbuckler style prestige classes (or possibly even base classes for Brechts) and use it for practitioners of that fighting style, I heartily approve of this change.

– Blair Monroe

Just noticed a possible awkward wording in the chapter 1 revision file. It might just be me, but I thought I’d bring it up incase it isn’t.

On page 15 of the PDF version, in the first paragraph under the FEATS header, you have this line: “These regional notations are not regional background feats; regional background feats are listed in the section on Races.”

When I investigate the section on Races, I cannot find anything refered to as ‘regional background feats’. The closest I seem to be able to find is the paragraph in the generic description of humans (pg. 1, left hand column) which reads: “Bonus feat. At first level, human characters receive an extra feat. Non-elite characters may only take a feat common in their region (as listed in Table 1-6: Common feats by region). Elite characters (such as player characters) may take any feat for which they are eligible.”

This seems like it is either contradicting the first statement or is a circular reference or an awkward wording of what was intended here.

– Blair Monroe

Thnaks for your gently answers to my doubt.
Then if a dwarf falls 30’ his DR also applies? I asume it is.

Originally posted by JanGunterssen@Mar 4 2004, 10:13 AM
Thnaks for your gently answers to my doubt.
Then if a dwarf falls 30’ his DR also applies? I asume it is.

No it does not.

The 3.5 rules on damage reduction are pretty much as follows “. . .ignore damage from most weapons, unarmed attacks, or natural weapons, but not from energy attacks, spells, spell-like abilities, or supernatural attacks.” See PHB pg 307, DMG pgs 291-292 (most detail), and MM pg 307 for specifics.

This was an issue that caused a lot of confusion and conflicting opinions in 2nd ed, but the 3.5 rules are pretty clear and removes this confusion, IMO.

Thanks again

Random thoughts I’m afraid:

Skills:
I agree with the previous poster that it would make more sense for only the first four bonus human skill points to be limited to the regional ones.

Druid:
Given that in birthright, druids are clerics of eric, shouldn’t they get knowledge religion as a class skill?

Magician:
The special abilities “Additional class skill” and “Bonus Cantrips” are weak compared to the other two options. Making the class skill one equivalent to “Cosmopolitan” from the BRCS and replacing Bonus Cantrips with an “Extra Slot” from Tome and Blood equivalent could help? Other than that, I really like it. Is the spell list the same?

Noble:
I liked the old one more than this one. First of all though, the stuff I like is:[ul][li]Favoured Region - though a +1 bonus would seem more balanced (see below)[/li][li]Wealth[/li][li]Adding Warcraft to their class skills (indeed, their skills are spot on)[/li][li]Presense[/li][/ul]A warning though: a 10th level noble with a bloodline of 32, Divine Aura and a bloodmark will have skills like Bluff, Gather Information, Intimidate, Sense Motive of +27+Cha and a Diplomacy of +29+Cha bonus before they choose feats. Now, according to the Epic book, a roll of 35 on a diplomacy check will turn someone from hostile to friendly and a roll of 50 will turn someone from hostile to helpful or from helpful to fanatically loyal. Further, a bluff check of 50+ acts as a non-magic Suggestion spell.

On the other hand: [ul][li]BAB: I don’t think this should be the same as that of a fighter - they may train well, but they don’t fight for their lives on a daily basis. Plus it makes the class too good for a one level dip for a melee character - the wealth, favoured region, bonus skill points are only balanced against a 2 point loss in potential HP.[/li][li]Resources: This is what roleplaying is for. Your favoured region, contributes to your diplomacy allowing you to barter favours and influence others. This bland mechanism is inappropriate for BR.[/li][li]Co-ordinate: The text of this: “Coordinate (Ex): At 3rd level, the noble gains the ability to guide the cooperation of other characters by making a Charisma check (DC 10 + the number of characters commanded). If successful, this increase the bonus granted by cooperation by +2.” doesn’t seem to make any sense to me and what I think it means (“That’s it lads, lift with your knees!”) seems a bit too much like the bard again.[/li][li]Battle Cry and Inspire Loyalty are out of place here - they really are the domain of the bard and don’t necessarily reflect what a generic noble should be able to do.[/li][/ul]
Feats[ul][li]Regional Arms Focus & Regional Elite Arms Focus: Thought they were fine the way they were and the new ability to change the weapon you favour doesn’t make sense.[/li][/ul]
CM.

CMonkey schrieb:

>This post was generated by the Birthright.net message forum.

> You can view the entire thread at:

> http://www.birthright.net/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=36&t=2317

>

> CMonkey wrote:

>…

> Magician:

> The special abilities “Additional class skill” and “Bonus Cantrips” are weak compared to the other two options. Making the class skill one equivalent to “Cosmopolitan” from the BRCS and replacing Bonus Cantrips with an “Extra Slot” from Tome and Blood equivalent could help? Other than that, I really like it. Is the spell list the same?

>

>

Something else about the Magician: The 2E Magician had access to the

Rogue and Wizard nonweapon proficienys. Shouldn´t he have "all Wizard

and Rogue skills as class skills" instead of listing only a selection of

them which also would be much shorter than the list?

If the Magician has a different spellselection with healing and

conjuration (what I still don´t like) than the 2E Magician who was

limited to all 1st and 2nd level spells and only illusion and divination

for level 3+, and as the 3E Sorceror just as the wizard has a d4, then I

see no reason to give the Magician a d6. He should rather have the same

as the wizard - or if he gets d6, Simple Weapon Proficiency and Light

Armour proficiency (which I also don´t like - is the Magician a Bard?)

and goes more into the direction of rogue with special abilitys for

spellcasting then he should not have any spells of level 3+ except

illusions and divinations.

If we look only at the adventure level, as a Magician as unblooded

character is generally not meant to rule, then with all the stuff about

the new Magician it should be carefully avoided to make him better than

a Wizard who specializes in Illusion and Divination and in 3.5 has to

forfeit 4 schools, with the same spellcasting benefits as the Magician

for being a specialist, but without receiving more weapons, light

armour, healing, more skill points and a wider skill selection.

bye

Michael

> Noble:

> I liked the old one more than this one. First of all though, the stuff I like is:[ul][li]Favoured Region - though a +1 bonus would seem more balanced (see below)[*]Wealth[*]Adding Warcraft to their class skills (indeed, their skills are spot on)[*]Presense[/ul]A warning though: a 10th level noble with a bloodline of 32, Divine Aura and a bloodmark will have skills like Bluff, Gather Information, Intimidate, Sense Motive of +27+Cha and a Diplomacy of +29+Cha bonus before they choose feats. Now, according to the Epic book, a roll of 35 on a diplomacy check will turn someone from hostile to friendly and a roll of 50 will turn someone from hostile to helpful or from helpful to fanatically loyal. Further, a bluff check of 50+ acts as a non-magic Suggestion spell.[/li]
>

> On the other hand: [ul][li]BAB: I dont think this should be the same as that of a fighter - they may train well, but they dont fight for their lives on a daily basis. Plus it makes the class too good for a one level dip for a melee character - the wealth, favoured region, bonus skill points are only balanced against a 2 point loss in potential HP.[*]Resources: This is what roleplaying is for. Your favoured region, contributes to your diplomacy allowing you to barter favours and influence others. This bland mechanism is inappropriate for BR.Co-ordinate: The text of this: “Coordinate (Ex): At 3rd level, the noble gains the ability to guide the cooperation of other characters by making a Charisma check (DC 10 + the number of characters commanded). If successful, this increase the bonus granted by cooperation by +2.” doesnt seem to make any sense to me and what I think it means ("[i]Thats it lads, lift with your knees!") seems[/li]
> a bit too much like the bard again.[li]Battle Cry and Inspire Loyalty are out of place here - they really are the domain of the bard and don`t necessarily reflect what a generic noble should be able to do.[*][/ul][/li]

Feats[ul][li]Regional Arms Focus & Regional Elite Arms Focus: Thought they were fine the way they were and the new ability to change the weapon you favour doesn`t make sense.[/ul][/li]
> CM.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

Allow me to mention here that flavour and feeling of character classes is more important than stereotypes; for example, why insist on this whole “this is too much bard-like, get it off”? I love bards, but that does not mean others should not grant a bonus to their allies! And believe me, you would feel a lot different if you fought alongside your Count: “Good lads, the Count is coming; let us go to battle under his proud banner!” and such stuff; morale is always improved when your leader is there with you, into the fray.

In any case, Coordinate is an intelligent mechanic, as are the various inspirational class features - notice how the Coordinate bonus applies only on bonuses for cooperation, not any case like the bard. Furthermore, a noble’s not just trained to defend himself fairly and simply land a blow or two on the open field (bard, cleric, druid, rogue), he is more like the militaristic figure who is able to wade through the battle and - just maybe - make it out unscathed, or at least alive.

As for the magician, I think Extra Slot is not only broken as a feat (since everyone will choose the highest spell level allowed to them by the feat so as to be able to cast any one spell of up to that level!), it also does not fit the “lesser path” motif introduced in Birthright. As for armour, hit die, and skills, no, I think allowing a magician free access to rogue skills such as Disable Device, Forgery, Hide, Listen, Move Silently, Search, Spot, yet give him only a d4 and no armour… well, that is broken! Only bards get no arcane spell failure chance for wearing armour, and light armour is not that mighty, not to mention the fact that a magician goes around more than the wizard and sorcerer.

Errors?

  • Under Lead the same text about “Matters of Justice” that have a DC of at least… just as under Administration?

Equipment:

  • The special Improved Mail is still listed under Scale Mail (+4)what is wrong, as it is not worse, but has to be better than CHAIN MAIL (+5) as it is the improved chain mail worn by Khinasi and Rjurik to match the heavy Plate of the Anuireans.
  • Naturally as the Anuireans actually use Plate Mail for which to match the others use Improved Mail, having Improved Mail available to Anuireans is nonsense.

Mounts:

  • The 2E version had the Vos ONLY with the Varsk, all horses were restricted to Anuireans (heavy Warhorse), An+Khinasi (medium Warhorse) and An+Kh+Elves (light Warhorse). considering that horses don´t get along with Varsks and “the weather and poor forage of lands make it difficult for the Vos to keep horses” (2E rulebook).
    That would mean that the “All” for horses should be replaced by a more restrictive list as in 2E.

  • Saber and Warspear:
    You give the Warspear a X4 critical, which neither Lance nor spear have in the PHB and the versatility to use it as both, but reduce the critical of the Saber (19-20/X2) as compared to the PHB Scimitar (18-20/X2)? If the longsword can have 1D8 and the same critical range as the 1D6 shortsword, then what is the reason that the 1D8 saber can´t have the same critical range as the Scimitar?
    bye
    Michael

Originally posted by RaspK_FOG@Mar 5 2004, 07:28 PM
Only bards get no arcane spell failure chance for wearing armour, and light armour is not that mighty, not to mention the fact that a magician goes around more than the wizard and sorcerer.

Actually all arcane casters suffer the same spell failure chance now, there is no exception for bards. It is just part of the 3/3.5 rules.

Just becasue a class has an armor proficiency doesn’t eliminate the arcane spell failure chance for that armor, it only eliminates the not proficient in armor ones.