Crossbows?

At 11:38 AM 11/27/2007, stv2brown1988 wrote:

>Maybe I got my history wrong but I thought most RL armies swtched to
>the Crossbow from the bow due to the fact that it was easier to
>train troops to hit a target with a crossbow instead of a
>bow. Having fired both when I was a kid I remember hitting the bale
>of hay with the crossbow almost everytime but missing completly with
>the bow for many shots. (This was within the first two range bands:))

Thats basically correct. Crossbows kind of straddle the deployment and technological line between bows and firearms. It is harder to hit targets under point blank range with a bow than with a crossbow, but once one has to deal with an arc of fire the crossbow is harder to use. Quite a lot of combat happens at relatively close range right up until the 20th century, though, the crossbow is generally better if not for the terrible ROF. IMO, crossbows get something of a break when it comes to ROF in D&D, especially heavy ones, but the speed with which many things happen is a bit questionable, so cest la vie.

That said, crossbows are “democratic” in the sense that they allow
for the common man to have a weapon that can penetrate the heavy
armor of his social superiors. They arent quite as democratic as firearms, of course, but thats certainly part of the appeal. One
needn`t have a dedicated social class that practices such weapons on
a full-time basis and employs very expensive military equipment. A
lot of the social and legal aspects of how crossbows were treated
comes from exactly this distinction. Many folks (the knightly
classes, that is) viewed the crossbow as the weapon of cowards or
otherwise morally repugnant people. That the crossbow eliminated
their social advantage is certainly a factor in that assessment.

So if one wanted to make the argument (and I suppose I just have)
that the crossbow`s development and deployment is as much a social
issue as a military one then I suppose one could. The technology
itself is not particularly esoteric, so other factors should be taken
into consideration. Using a crossbow is as much a social statement
as it is a military one, and all that has to do with the social
conditions of feudalism after the social effects of the Black Death
and the beginning of the Renaissance.

>I was looking for something that either made it easier to hit with a
>crossbow or a rule about mustering crossbowmen or training levies
>into crossbowmen is easier/cheaper/faster than normal archers
>(bows). Does this make any sense to anyone else?

The more I look at this kind of stuff the more I like two things:

First, armor should have a DR function, not simply an AC
function. Second, weapons should have a Penetration (Pen) value in
addition to a damage die/dice and critical hit values. After all,
someone is not more difficult to hit because he`s wearing armor; the
blow is just absorbed or deflected because of that armor. The
deflection aspect of armor still works as an AC mod, but it should be
reduced and factored along with a DR function. There are D20 books
that do precisely that. Basically, the AC mod for armor is split
into AC and DR, generally right in half. Personally, I think all the
armor types should be taken into consideration on an individual
basis, with DR interacting with damage values the same way BAB and AC
interact… but I digress into homebrewing that might be a bit more
than what you were asking about.

Gary

A trained archer/crossbowman doesn’t have only better aim,but can recharge faster.
So bad archers and crossbowmen have nearly the same rate of fire,but a good archer has an excellent rate of fire,the only problem is that archer’s training require a lot of time and for this reason France never used the longbow.

Now that I’m thinking about both longbow and the soldier of “Zulu” are Welsh…Welsh are supermen!

I take an AC bonus for armour into account, but the AC bonus will probably be about halved for each type of armour. I’m using the several systems outlined in Unearthed Arcana and the combat system of Conan d20 as a base. I especially like UA’s idea that armour converts damage to non lethal damage. That way, combat mostly plays out as normal, but there’s a greater chance for unconsciousness and armour can be a real live-saver.

With regard to how certain armour types interact with different types of damage, I believe that such a system might be more realistic, but it would also be nigh unplayable. Back in 1st and 2nd edition, I tried once or thrice to use the rules how different weapons affect different armour AC boni. It was quite impossible without the game grinding to a halt while the players or I tried to make sense of the complicated tables.
However, assigning an armour piercing value (AP) to weapons takes some of your concerns into acount, I believe. An example:

Tordek wears a set of full plate, which offers him an AC bonus of +5 and also converts 10 points of damage into non-lethal damage. He his hit by a club (AP 0) for 6 points of damage. Since the club has AP 0, all of this damage is converted into non-lethal damage. He certainly feels the hit, but it’s in no way life-threatening to him. Next he is attacked with a warhammer and takes 8 points of damage. Since the warhammer has an AP of 7, only 3 points of damage are non-lethal, 5 are lethal damage. Ouch, that really hurt.

A heavy crossbow, to stay at least somewhat on topic, might have an AP of 10 or even more, applying all of its damage as lethal against Tordek.

Well, I haven’t crunched the numbers yet and several questions remain, as what to do with enhancement boni - do these just add to AC or also to the damage conversion rate of armour? Nevertheless, you get the general idea, I hope.

I’ve re-read your system and the accompanying discussion and your system looks viable enough. However, I’d like to know for what level of play you have used it so far. I believe your system works fine for low to mid-levels of play, but might break down somewhat later, as your defence progression is quite slow compared to BAB (and discounting a later proliferation of magical armour).

Another point is that I would prefer a bit more differentiation between different armours, but that’s personal taste.

As a sidenote regarding Geeman’s reply , Conan d20 uses two types of defence, one for dodging, one for parrying. Character classes are usually only good at one type of defence, and each type cannot be used under certain circumstances. For example, you need an unoccupied 5-foot-square next to you to dodge and you can’t parry missile attacks. This is once again a bit more realistic, but I fear it might also confuse my players.

Now that I`m thinking about both longbow and the soldier of “Zulu” are Welsh…Welsh are supermen!

And they can sing across more octaves than the Zulu! The “Men of Harlech” scene rawked. But, it was the rest of the same Welsh battalion that got chopped up at Isandlhwana, see the movie “Zulu Dawn.” The 24th was something of a hard-luck regiment, they often got caught in sticky spots.

Lee.

Honesty forces me to add to Lee’s comment to note that the “English longbow” is about as English as Glenmorangie… we swiped the design off the Welsh of course.

Who adapted a viking bow that was quite old.