Dhoura

Discussion thread for Dhoura. If you would like to add a comment, click the Post Reply button.

Dhoure:

The dhoura is the favorite ship of Khinasi corsairs because its speed, mobility, capability to move without wind, and its ability to operate in shallow water – crucial for hiding in coastal waters before pouncing on a passing ship – make it ideal for war and piracy.

Zebec:

Khinasi captains greatly favor zebecs as corsairs, because they are built with a narrow floor to achieve a higher speed than their victims, but with a considerable beam in order to enable them to carry an extensive sail-plan. The lateen rig of the zebec allows for the ship to sail close hauled to the wind often giving it an advantage in pursuit or escape.

So which one is the favourite of the “corsairs”?

And which meaning of Corsair are you using? Just any pirate? Or a sealord who just happens to have a regent’s soldiers onboard his ships (as the Ottoman lords did along the Barbary Coast), and targets the ships belonging to enemies of the regent (i.e. “sanctioned” piracy)?

(reference: The Wordsworth Dictionary of Pirates)

Sorontar

Corsairs are sanctioned pirates. They get their name because they have a Lettre de Course issued by the crown.

Zebecs are good ships for corsairs because as large ships effective as warships, they can attack almost anything, and being maneuverable, make good attack ships. Hence greatly favor.

The dhoura is smaller, but capable of attacking any merchant ship. Hence the favorite.

I can add a reference to the dhoura, in zebec, as in second only to the dhoura. A dhoura gives a better rate of return, but the only thing that would stop a zebec is a warship. So zebecs are also good against dhoura.

So, is there a difference between corsairs and privateers? Sir Francis Drake was a privateer and was effectively part of the Black Ops English navy of the time.

No, a privateer is a corsair and vise versa. The British government issued a Letter of Marque and Reprisal to authorize privateers. The French issued its Lettre de Course, and so its privateers were known as corsairs. As the English would encounter other state protected privateers, it called them by the same name. So in the English world we tend to call our sanctioned merchant raiders “privateers” and call everyone else’s, “corsairs” or if we intend to treat them as outlaws, “pirates”.

Drake was authorized by the crown, split his take with the crown, and represented himself as a agent of the crown. Had he been captured he would hope his letter authorizing his actions would grant him the protections as a prisoner of war, meaning he would be ransomed, traded, or released as part of a diplomatic settlement. The Spanish threatened to treat him like a pirate, placed a bounty on his head, and had nothing to gain from England by recognizing his letters of marque. At various times Drake held ranks in the admiralty (he was, for example, a vice admiral during the Armada campaign), but that had more to do with placing him in a chain of command over others than it did with extending the crown’s responsibility for his actions.

You’re a mine of information, Kenneth. Thanks! :slight_smile:

At 02:38 AM 7/31/2008, Thelandrin wrote:

>So, is there a difference between corsairs and privateers? Sir
>Francis Drake was a privateer and was effectively part of the Black
>Ops English navy of the time.

Corsair is used more broadly than privateer. As has been noted,
originally it meant those who operate under official sanction, but it
came to describe those pirates who adopted (or were seen as having
adopted) a more swashbuckling “style” that might be considered the
stereotypical pirate. The Barbary pirates, for instance, were
sometimes called Turkish or Ottoman Corsairs and you can bet the
French king never signed off on that one…

Of course, privateers often went above and beyond the scope of their
supposed mandate too… Once out of sight of land captains and
crews tend to have their own ideas about who is a fair target. From
the POV of the merchant privateer, corsair or pirate is a matter of semantics.

Given that were talking about the Khinasi, the use of the word "corsair" to describe a pirate ship/crew would more likely be based on the Barbary pirates than the French version of the idea, but even under the French concept, a pirate might just as well describe himself as a corsair in order to gain some sort of hint of legitimacy. Many privateers were sanctioned after the fact when they returned home laden with booty because few monarchs turn down a share of such goods when they are actually handed over. Since returning home with a lot of ill-gotten gains is the goal of any pirate they might very well hope and expect to be given such treatment. Of course, theres a good chance they might also simply be hanged and (a
portion) of their booty returned to the nations from whom it was
stolen, but that`s the kind of risk a pirate always takes.

Gary

The added benefit of treating them as Barbary corsairs is because of how easy it is to link it to the Birthright way of thinking. As I indicated in my original query, the Barbary sealords were just governors of the coastal ports along the Babary Coast (North Africa). They were pretty much regents who were in their own domain, but technically they were part of the Ottoman Empire. They were expected to transport Turkish soldiers on their ships, not their own, so the sailors were not the fighters (much). To quote my reference:

Barbary rulers treated piracy as a business, regulated through the corsair’s guild (Taife Reisi). …
The Barbary States had a dual nature, as both corsair havens and inland empires. Power thus was shared between two groups - the Corsair’s guild and the military garrison of Janissaries. Both guilds were made up of outsiders and rarely accepted local Muslims as members.
From the beginning, the Barbary States were relatively autonomous. The sultan’s authority rested in a Beylerbey sent from Istanbul. Although the sultan continued to confirm the man they nominated, the Janissary garrisons effectively controlled government and taxation from the 1590s.

So the provincial regent is a Guilder that is a vassal of the Emperor, but the Law Holding is controlled by another regent, who is also the Emperor’s vassal, but only has a working agreement with the Guilder. I believe that theoretically the Law regent had rank over the Guilder, but whether that was exercised much, I have no idea.

Or something like that. It’s a good book as a starting reference.

Sorontar.

No, the Sultan signed off on that one.

But as the English already had a word for state sanctioned merchant raiders, they simply applied this word to a new context.

Turkish use of private navies extends back as far as the Turks being in Anatolia. Çaka, Bey of Smyrna built his own navy and waged his own war on the Byzantines c. 1090. They never really stopped using military entrepreneurs.

Suleiman the Magnificent gave such a patent to Khair ad Din, known to Europeans as Barbarossa. He was supposed to build a great fleet and wage war on the Europeans (especially the Spanish and Venetians, but anyone who crossed them). His general strategy was to prey on merchant shipping, land on unsuspecting coastlines and pillage, and to sell captives into slavery. Through these means he funded a navy. In whatever time he had left over, he advanced the interests of Suleiman. But as far as the Sultan was concerned, just being a menace to Venetian and Habsburg interests was a bargain. After all, the investment for Suleiman was very small. As is frequently the case, the most successful forms of warfare pay for themselves.

Further, keep in mind that all warfare from the medieval period to the 19th century, was essentially private contractors working under a patent from some authority.

[i]At 06:55 PM 7/31/2008, kgauck wrote:

>>The Barbary pirates, for instance, were sometimes called Turkish or Ottoman Corsairs and you can bet the French king never signed off on that one…
>
>No, the Sultan signed off on that one.[/i]

Sure, but my point was that a lot of these folks that the Sultan (or several other Ottoman officials who did support the activities of the
Barbary pirates) signed off on were freelance BEFORE they gained official recognition, and we shouldn’t quibble about when the term “corsair” might officially apply to them because the term is used much more broadly than “privateer.” Later, many of the folks called “corsairs” under the Turks would really have to be seen as the equivalent of an official navy. Several of the Barbary admirals worked their way up through a “system” of small, sometimes officially supported piratical endeavors, but once such a person is being given twelve, twenty or a hundred ships to command were leaving the realm of pirate raiding and are into regular naval actions. Such an admiral and his fleet are still called "corsairs" without straining the term, but one wouldnt still see them as the equivalent of a “privateer.”

>Further, keep in mind that all warfare from the medieval period to the 19th century, was essentially private contractors working under a patent from some authority.

“Contractors” is, of course, a very modern term for people engaging in military roles and it`s misleading on several levels, but we needn’t delve too far into the semantics of current euphemisms… Suffice it to say that what we are calling “contractors” really represent a sort of small private (corporate) standing army, while something like “corsair” is going to describe a range of naval operations from small pirate raids to full-fledged naval landing operations.

Regardless, there have always been and still are a significant number of such fighters (a look at the number of “contractors” in Iraq right
now makes one wonder if things have really changed all that much) but by the 17-18th century there were a lot of what we`d recognize as
standing armies of regulars, and nobody would mistake them for mercenaries. In fact, you can find such fighters without too much difficulty going back a good 500 years before the 19th century.

But the point is that the term “corsair” could be used to apply to what we would recognize as a standing military force engaging in commerce raiding and all the standard naval operations that any other navy engages in except the modern deployment of air power. Later the term applies even more particularly the a “style” of pirate that goes with the idea of a sort of “gentleman of the sea” to whom official recognition might or might not be of interest.

“Privateer” is more particular. A privateer is, of course, just a pirate who works for the other side, but one should bear in mind that a privateer might just take his role as a commerce raider more seriously and abide by some sort of ethical standard. Just as likely not, but at least one has a shot at being allowed to live if faced with a “privateer” who takes the idea seriously. On the other hand, the idea of a “corsair” implies a much more unpleasant encounter. The Ottoman corsairs were often looking to loot, pillage and rape; take slaves; slaughter civilians; even engage in a war of conquest. Later “corsairs” who operate under no official sanction are simply pirates.

Gary

This post is full of restatements of my earlier posts, thrown back as if they are arguing with what I said, attacks on the use of modern terms used to clarify earlier posts that lacked them, on the false understanding that period terms were confusing, and full of distinctions that were either covered before are don’t address the issues previously under discussion.

This is another example of a bad faith attempt by Gary to poison a thread.

we shouldn`t quibble about when the term “corsair” might officially apply to them

No one is quibbling, but you. take your own advice.

A lot of these folks that the Sultan signed off on were freelance BEFORE they gained
official recognition

No one said otherwise. What might have been a useful addition for the reader unfamiliar with early modern conditions on the sea is instead presented as a correction where none is needed, because no one actually stated otherwise. If this kind of thing happened once in a while, one might be able to overlook it, but it happens all the time, so that one cannot trust to good will and consider it a poorly worded reply.

I would have thought that before receiving official sanction as a privateer, it is obvious that the person had a boat engaged in some other occupation, either as a merchant who has lost either markets or safe trade routes, or as a pirate preying mostly on the country that is now an enemy. It may be presumptuous to assume that this is obvious, but you go one better. You presume it is secret knowledge accessible only to yourself. Instead of just offering new information, it has to be stated as a correction, even if it is entirely new. That’s malicious.

Later, many of the folks called “corsairs” under the Turks would really have to be seen as the equivalent of an official navy.

At various times Drake held ranks in the admiralty (he was, for example, a vice admiral during the Armada campaign)

Why in post #10 offer as a correction information already established in post #5? Certainly we both know that the distinction between a state navy and a force of privately own ships operating under the colors of a state is a matter of who holds the deed to the ship and what the ship does in peacetime. The spectrum of merchant ship to privateer to navy has no clear boundaries, which you say mention above. We could go in new directions, such a naval reserves and how ship design breaks this easy spectrum, but I’ll leave that for now.

An admiral and his fleet are still called “corsairs” without straining the term, but one would`t still see them as the equivalent of a “privateer.”

This is basically the difference between “our guys” and “their guys.” We know the difference between our own armed merchants, our own privateers, and our own navy because we have inside knowledge. When dealing with a foreign country (say Spain looking at England) there is considerable asymmetric information. Elizabeth preferred to keep a layer of distance between her privateers for exactly this purpose, because she could plausibly deny, and pay for any attacks she wanted to disavow. But Spain knew Drake was a privateer, they chose to use this ruse in the opposite direction, adopting the position that he was a pirate. Intentional asymetric information can be used by both sides.

When dealing with a different culture as well, clear distinctions between pirates, privateers, and a state navy get even muddier. When complicated by captains and ships moving between one category to another, why expect that one could separate corsairs from other categories? Especially when Turkish and Arabic forces fall back more and more on hit and run strategies as the leading naval powers progress technologically.

Its also worth remembering in semantic discussions that people unhappy with another party are liable to use the least favorable term available, even if its not technically accurate. One example being the Barbary Pirates. Given that the landed rulers of Tunis, Tripoli, Algiers, Tangier, and so on were protecting and encouraging this activity, collecting “tribute” to ignore a particular flag, its not real piracy.

Words also take on new meaning, so that a ship good for corsairs can be called a corsair, as can tactics of corsairs make you candidate for being a corsair. Because privateers describe our licensed trade warfare, that term remains precise, while the activities of other countries with unclear relationships to their trade warriors, with different customs, or whose technology forces them to a limited pallet of tactics regardless of the provenance of their warships. But certainly the nature of a living language is not a secret.

I do like the discussion mine you even if your riping each other a new one just politely :smiley:

I`m beginning to wonder: is there privateering in BR?

Lee.

At 12:30 PM 8/2/2008, Lee wrote:

>I`m beginning to wonder: is there privateering in BR?

Well, in the sense that weve been discussing privateering (officially recognized pirates actually given a certificate to legalize their actions) probably not much. That is, most of Cerilia wouldnt be that interested in concepts of official
recognition. Only the Brecht and Anuireans might find some sort of
solace in the idea of actually licensing pirates, but it should be
noted that most of the domains in BR arent really large enough to lend a lot of credibility to such a patent. I could see Muden, Danigau, Boeruine or Avanil doing it. Grabentod probably doesnt
really recognize the difference between a privateer and a regular
naval unit…

As a social custom, though, it`s as old as nation/states and boats
big enough for a dozen sailors, so if one has trade by sea one is
going to have some sort of privateer even if his mandate is vague.

Gary

If there is a substantial sea trade, then when a general war breaks out those ships need to continue to make money for their owners. I think privateers outnumber dedicated warships by four or five to one.

At 06:19 PM 8/1/2008, kgauck wrote:

>This post is full of restatements of my earlier posts, thrown back
>as if they are arguing with what I said, attacks on the use of
>modern terms used to clarify earlier posts that lacked them, on the
>false understanding that period terms were confusing, and full of
>distinctions that were either covered before are don`t address the

issues previously under discussion.

This is another example of a bad faith attempt by Gary to poison a thread.

::Sigh::

Let me first say that my general policy in recent years has been to
ignore the personal attacks directly made toward me. Of course, its annoying to have to wade through accusations of trolling and flames in order to respond to the actual substantial points being made, but in order to make some sort of progress Ive found that to be the only
way to get things done. However, its getting increasingly difficult to separate the wheat from the chaff, and this is getting to be something of a regular thing. In this last post, the personal attacks and accusations are tied up with the actual points so firmly that I really just dont have the time to try to unweave them, so Im going to go ahead and address the whole muddle. Unfortunately, that means Im going to have to put a few things up that are going to be
directed straight back at Kenneth, and that`s not going to be pleasant.

So, if anyone would care to take a quick look at the progression of
this thread I think youll see that if anyone has been restating earlier arguments as if they were his own it isnt me. Kenneth`s
stance in posts #3 and #5 is that “privateer” and “corsair” are
essentially synonymous. In response to the question “So, is there a
difference between corsairs and privateers?” he responds “No, a
privateer is a corsair and vise versa.” He offers no further
information on the terms.

Now, Ive made a particular study of naval history, and focused quite a bit on medieval Ottoman history, so I know thats not true. It
fact, it`s a common misconception that many people who have only read
casually on the subject make. Yes, the etymology of the word
“corsair” comes from the French use of the word in a Lettre de
Course, but unlike a “privateer” which has pretty much kept its
meaning as someone who had received a Letter of Marque and Reprisal,
the word “corsair” very quickly was used in a broader sense that went
beyond its origin.

[As an interesting note for those who are still hoping for new
information on this issue: both “Marque” and “Course” have French
origins, but “Marque” in English generally means things like border,
frontier or the signs used to designate such things. A “marque” is a
model or brand. “Course” is used in this sense as someone who sets a
course, but in the French the word also has to do with chasing and
plunder. A “corsair” is, therefore, a hunter at sea. Further, the
word “course” also means unrefined, so it lends itself neatly to the
idea that a pirate might be a sort of vulgar parody of a
gentleman. Therefore, The Letter of Marque has a sort of official
sound to it as it implies that one must “show the flag” or otherwise
illustrate one`s allegiance–even as a freelancer. On the other
hand, the origin of the word “corsair” goes towards more, shall we
say, zealous types of piracy.]

Now normally, Id let this kind of thing go because I dont really
have a lot of free time to dedicate to the BR community, and what
time I do have I would rather dedicate to something that is going to
turn into a PDF, so I cant be concerned about common misconceptions unless they have some sort of bearing on the situation. That is, it doesnt really matter if George Washington cut down a cherry tree or
not if one is discussing what cherry blossoms smell like, but it does
make a difference if one is talking about the concept of honesty to
begin with. In this case, its significant to note that "privateer" and "corsair" arent really the same thing because the word “corsair”
is being applied in a very different sense. Noting that French
origin of the word “corsair” helps us a bit in understanding the
development of the word, but without more information it doesn`t make
sense why that word should be used to describe the Khinasi. Once one
knows about the extended use of the word, particularly to describe
groups like the Barbary pirates, it makes better sense.

>>we shouldn`t quibble about when the term “corsair” might officially

apply to them

No one is quibbling, but you. take your own advice.

Im going to ask again that you to stop editing my text to remove the original context and then respond to that truncated clause. Doing so misrepresents the full meaning of the statement. What I said in full was "Sure, but my point was that a lot of these folks that the Sultan (or several other Ottoman officials who did support the activities of the Barbary pirates) signed off on were freelance BEFORE they gained official recognition, and we shouldnt quibble about when the term
“corsair” might officially apply to them because the term is used
much more broadly than privateer."

Clearly, you took this use of the word “quibble” as if it were a
personal attack, which it wasn`t. Note please the use of the word
“we” there as reference to the entire community–or at least anyone
reading the thread–and how it is used in the texts that we all read.

That said, your response makes me think you dont know what a quibble is, so let me note that to quibble is to cite trivial or irrelevant distinctions in order to obscure the full meaning of an issue. In this case, citing the origin of the term "corsair" as being someone who was issued a Lettre de Coarse would be a quibble because it incorrectly limits the term to a very particular segment of those who were called "corsairs" when, in fact, many more than just they were so named. I said that the word "corsair" is broader than that. What I said could not, therefore, be a quibble since I was being inclusive. It is trivial to the understanding of the Ottoman, Carribean or other pirates referred to as "corsairs" that the term comes from the French. Its interesting, but does not convey the whole truth.

This is the kind of thing that Id normally ignore or cut from a reply, but I feel obliged to leave it in this particular post because its pretty much the point. If one is asking what a “corsair” is
then one needs to get the big picture, not parse the meaning down to
its Gaelic origins and equate it with another term.

>>A lot of these folks that the Sultan signed off on were freelance
>>BEFORE they gained
>>official recognition
>
>No one said otherwise. What might have been a useful addition for
>the reader unfamiliar with early modern conditions on the sea is
>instead presented as a correction where none is needed, because no
>one actually stated otherwise. If this kind of thing happened once
>in a while, one might be able to overlook it, but it happens all the
>time, so that one cannot trust to good will and consider it a poorly
>worded reply.

You gave me very little to go on there other than your previous
comments, which didnt show that you understood the difference between a "privateer" and a "corsair." When you responded that the Sultan signed off on the Ottoman corsairs that reads that youre
saying they must have had such approval they would be called
“corsairs” because in other posts youve directly equated the two. Perhaps thats not what you meant, but as all you responded
with was “No, the Sultan signed off on that one” it certainly reads
as if that was what you were saying. At the very least, it does read
as if you had missed, misunderstood or were ignoring the larger point
being made, which was that we wouldn`t normally consider a pirate a
privateer BEFORE he got his Letter of Marque, but a corsair would be
called a corsair before and after any official recognition by the
Sultan. The added information was to show the distinction that you
appeared not to have grasped.

This does seem to happen fairly frequently, but Ill take issue with the comment that it is "a bad faith attempt... to poison a thread." Since youve made that accusation or one like it a couple
of times recently, I feel obliged to discuss it a bit:

Im interested in free and open discussion around here. Thats
it. I wouldnt derive any pleasure from confusing issues or trying to halt a conversation, and if I did... well, lets just say I
wouldnt bother being subtle about it. Itd be very clear… The
fact is, I delete more text from my messages to the list than I send
simply because I go through them carefully before I send them and try
to remove things that might be seen as a personal attack or even that
I think might be provocative. Id encourage you to do the same. Lets try to keep this civil.

I would have thought that before receiving official sanction as a
privateer, it is obvious that the person had a boat engaged in some
other occupation, either as a merchant who has lost either markets
or safe trade routes, or as a pirate preying mostly on the country
that is now an enemy. It may be presumptuous to assume that this is
obvious, but you go one better. You presume it is secret knowledge
accessible only to yourself. Instead of just offering new
information, it has to be stated as a correction, even if it is
entirely new. That`s malicious.

Nobody, myself included, has written anything in this thread even
remotely close to “secret knowledge” so that particular rhetoric
strikes me as badly overstated. You do yourself a disservice by
framing the argument in such overwrought terms.

Anyway, lots of misconceptions here… First of all, I did not say
and would not assume that someone who received official sanction as a
privateer had the kind of experience you suggest because thats not actually correct. Likewise, I didnt “go one better” with those
assumptions because I know they are are actually false; I never would
have made them in the first place. So this maliciousness seems to be
based on some erroneous assumptions. To wit:

You say that you think it would be obvious that privateers (you do
mean actual privateers, not the broader term “corsairs” here, right?)
must have had a boat and engaged in merchant or other occupation (I
assume you mean nautical occupation) before they got a Letter of
Marque. Id not have said that and did not because I know that many privateers had no substantial naval experience whatever before they received their Letter of Marque. Governments who issue such documents do so because they are generally on the weaker side of the conflict, so they are not usually particular to whom they issue them. Theres very little to lose about issuing a Letter of
Marque. They are written in the hope of creating the naval
equivalent of a guerrilla war in which “civilians” attack other
civilians, but governments have a buffer between themselves and
responsibility for that kind of action. One isnt particular who one employs in such a role. Therefore, many governments would give a Letter of Marque to anyone who could get together the money to launch an expedition, or claim to be able to get that money together. Generally speaking, of course, most folks would have some sort of nautical experience before going off to become privateers, but thats not the assumption and, with a little consideration its clear why they didnt have such a requirement.

Second, many Letters of Marque were issued to people who had no
experience with piracy even if they did have experience with
sailing. A Letter of Marque could (and was) given to ordinary
merchantmen who had not engage in piracy before under the assumption
that they might have the opportunity to do so during wartime. The
assumption was that such people would have the opportunity for
commerce raiding as part of their regular activities, so why not give
them the option. That does not mean, however, that they actually had
been pirates before they got their Letter of Marque.

What I DID say is that many of those who were officially recognized
by the Sultan were successful corsairs before that recognition. Yet
one would call them corsairs both before and after that
recognition. I did NOT say that anyone who received a Letter of
Marque (or official recognition by any government) was “person had a
boat engaged in some other occupation, either as a merchant who has
lost either markets or safe trade routes, or as a pirate preying
mostly on the country that is now an enemy.”

I assume this is a mistaken, rather than malicious, rewrite of what I
did say, so Ill not level that accusation back at you. However, I would request that you read more carefully before levelling such accusations. In fact, I think you should consider carefully before levelling such attacks at all. Even if youre going to assume bad
faith, it does no good to accuse someone of it without some pretty
hefty proof. Instead, simply make your arguments and trust to the
intelligence of the BR community to decide for themselves.

>>Later, many of the folks called “corsairs” under the Turks would
>>really have to be seen as the equivalent of an official navy.
>
>>At various times Drake held ranks in the admiralty (he was, for
>>example, a vice admiral during the Armada campaign)
>
>Why in post #10 offer as a correction information already
>established in post #5? Certainly we both know that the distinction
>between a state navy and a force of privately own ships operating
>under the colors of a state is a matter of who holds the deed to the
>ship and what the ship does in peacetime. The spectrum of merchant
>ship to privateer to navy has no clear boundaries, which you say
>mention above. We could go in new directions, such a naval reserves
>and how ship design breaks this easy spectrum, but I`ll leave that for now.

I wrote that information because you were talking about one case
(Drake) who was a privateer, while the question was about
corsairs. Using Drake as an example of a corsair doesn`t make a lot
of sense. At various points in his career he might be described as a
corsair in the loosest sense of the word, while at other points he
would be a corsair in the stricter sense that you were first
suggesting (“No, a privateer is a corsair and vise versa.”)

Gary

Gary and I have had the opportunity to take some of this off-line and I know for my part I was not taking the most charitable reading of his posts as the basis of my replies. In hindsight I wish that I had contacted him back during the wiki thread, but I didn’t.

In any event, the vitriol is all worked out, and I retract any personal attacks I made.

As to the core issue, as I see it, the state has been gradually assuming a monopoly of violence begining in the 14th century and really not completed until the 20th (and then only where the state has been triumphant). Before and during this period, private participation in war is common, and determining whether someone is a an independent actor, an independent contractor, or a state agent can be difficult. People can occupy two of the three positions at the same time, but generally not all three.

My general opinion is that true examples of totally private actors are rare (or are such small scale operators) and that totally state actors are rare. Generally everyone from the mercenary captain to the chancellor are both private and state actors. So my own view is that true pirates, independent operators at war with everyone, are rare, small scale, or limited to regions of significant lawlessness.

In Birthright, I think most ships preying on shipping, are connected to guilds, and are part of the cut-throat nature of guild interaction. True pirates, a ship with no connections to any domain, would be rare. Likewise most domains actually own a handfull of ships, when the number of ships who operate from a given port may number in the hundreds.

While it is possible to make other sensible categories of these things, those are the one’s I am using.

At 09:18 AM 8/14/2008, kgauck wrote:

>Gary and I have had the opportunity to take some of this off-line
>and I know for my part I was not taking the most charitable reading
>of his posts as the basis of my replies. In hindsight I wish that I
>had contacted him back during the wiki thread, but I didn`t.

It looks like that long post through a monkey wrench into the link
between the list and the boards (its very length was the problem, which I suppose one should take as a hint as to when one is going in the wrong direction...) and I was actually rather glad it didnt make
an appearance since I didnt think it really did much to improve things, and I now consider the matter resolved. In this particular thread, for instance, I dont think anyone has really disagreed with
anyone else in any significant way. Rather, we`ve been adding
material around one another in a sort of circle.

>In Birthright, I think most ships preying on shipping, are connected
>to guilds, and are part of the cut-throat nature of guild
>interaction. True pirates, a ship with no connections to any domain,
>would be rare. Likewise most domains actually own a handfull of
>ships, when the number of ships who operate from a given port may
>number in the hundreds.

“True pirates” in this sense would indeed live lives that were
brutish and short. One can loot and pillage only for so long without
some sort of safe haven to re-equip, re-arm, heal, etc. This strikes
me as significant in a couple of ways for our purposes in BR:

  1. Those who engage in piracy are probably going to have a connection
    to a regent and, therefore, they will bear in mind that their
    behavior will have effects in the long run. They will be in it
    mostly for the profit.

  2. Those who are true pirates are going to be fatalistic in a way
    that most folks might find difficult to comprehend. They have to
    know their actions are likely to end only with their own
    demise. They`d be all the more brutal for that knowledge.

Gary