So you’re saying that no elf, anywhere, ever engaged in a lawful act?
If you really mean to say that, then you’re suggesting that elves are more strongly aligned than any other being in the multiverse. Even outsiders can engage in cross-alignment acts or even change alignment - it’s very rare, but it can happen.
On the other hand, if you simply mean that it is rare for an elf to ever engage in a lawful activity, then there should be no PC restriction.
You see, to be lawful, you must create or subject yourself to a more or less defined ethical system or number of axioms; in fact, being lawful is all about abiding to a code of conduct even when it would be inconvenient to do just that.
There are two problems with this.
Firstly, your definition of lawful is not accurate. All alignments follow a number of axioms; they are, however, different axioms, which is how one tells alignments apart. For example, lawful good characters believe in the greatest good for the greatest number, and might be inclined to sacrifice a little freedom for the greater good; chaotic good characters would consider a sacrifice of freedom to be too high a price to pay, since freedom is one of the things that are important to their notion of what is “good”. Both are following axioms, they’re just different axioms.
But let us suppose for the moment that your definition of lawful is accurate. In 3rd edition, being lawful simply means that on the whole you follow a defined ethical system or number of axioms. It doesn’t mean that you always do so, and it certainly (crucially!) doesn’t mean that you must do so. If you consistently fail to do so, you will drift into a neutral or even chaotic alignment, but there are no penalties for this in 3rd edition; alignment is no longer a straitjacket.
(guardsman example snipped)
Sidhelien do not act that way; sure, they do have laws and traditions, but anyone can do that. The difference from a creature with a lawful alignment and a sociologically speaking lawful person is that the lawful alignment signifies a lawful philosophy; in other words, a person with a lawful alignment is a sociologically speaking lawful person, yet not every sociologically speaking lawful person has a lawful alignment.
Actually I disagree with that as well. A lawful creature is not necessarily a sociologically lawful person. Lawful Evil crime lords are an obvious counter example.
But in any case, saying that “Sidhelien do not act that way” is a very strong statement. Saying “very few Sidhelien act that way” or even “Sidhelien very rarely act that way” are fine; that is the equivalent of a “Usually non-lawful” alignment, which is the strongest any non-outsider race has.
An elf on Aebrynis does not ever, but one’s very nature, dedicate oneself to such sets of ideals or axioms; one may follow custom and tradition due to good reason, but one won’t even think before lying if telling the truth would be disastrous (well, in most cases).
Lawful characters are not necessarily truthful. Lawful evil, again, is an obvious counter example, but frankly even a lawful good character is not required to be honest all the time. Paladins, maybe, might have restrictions that are that harsh - some DMs would suggest that a paladin is morally obligated to tell the truth even to a demon prince - but then again, paladins have strict rules for what happens if they engage in chaotic or evil activities. Note that they are not by any means restricted from performing such activities - they can do whatever they wish, but they suffer a penalty if they do.
That’s the 3rd edition way.
Another thing: an act alone rarily if ever in any campaign changes one’s alignment instantaneously; it should really be a very serious transgression of one’s erstwhile alignment to guarantee such a heavy-handed reversal…
Or a series of minor acts, yes?
In the end, to put it simply, a sidhelien can simply NOT become lawful; if a player portrays his character lawfully, inform him of the fact so that he stops.
And if he doesn’t?
You should not be telling your players how to act. In 3rd edition, the accepted means of enforcing alignment is to impose penalties for infractions (c.f. paladins, barbarians, et al). So if elves really are as strongly aligned as you suggest - and I reiterate that this is absolutely unprecedented for any non-outsider in 3rd edition - then the rules need to be a lot more explicit, ideally spelling out what happens to an elf who becomes lawful.
Because with all the best intentions it can happen. What if a chaotic good elf puts on a cursed helm of opposite alignment? Are they simply immune to the effects of such items?
Either:
[ul]
[li]PC elves should not be restricted to non-lawful alignments; no other humanoid is, and it has no effect on Sidhelien culture as a whole to allow that a rare number of them are lawful (any more than the occasional good goblin or orog affects their culture), or
[/li][li]The penalties for becoming lawful need to be spelled out, or
[/li][li]It needs to be made explicit that Sidhelien are completely incapable of lawful acts, and immune to any sort of magical compulsion that would force them to engage in them.
[/li][/ul]
The first of these three options makes the most sense, but at the very least one of them needs to be adopted; the current rules are inconsistent with the 3rd edition definition of the way alignment works.