In a mixed race group, how does one neutralize the Khinasi Wizards Oath to destroy all wizards who do not adhere to their four oaths? Can it be neutralized?
If you feel that the oaths are causing trouble in your group you can as the DM decide to allow some relatively lax criteria for renouncing the oaths. You can even say that the oaths only hold for those whom Rilni holds any power over, i.e. not the elves. Personally I don’t think it should be very easy, as it is one of the things I find rather interesting with the Khinasi setting. While never became a real issue, the last time a player asked me this question I said it would at least require a wish spell cast by another magic user.
If one use Djinni and Efreeti in a Khinasi campaign it might be an interesting plot to either capture or free a powerful genie so it could cast a wish to break the oaths. If one want to make it even more difficult one could require one wish for each of the five oaths.
Another interesting question is whether there is some way for other oath bound wizards to know if a wizard has renounced his oaths. Could make for some interesting roleplaying if a character who is freed from his oaths has to constantly try avoid detection by other wizards.
Well, it would make sense for the Khinasi Wizard to attack if he witnesses another non Khinasi mage doing something that would break the oath, like disobaying the ruler, burning books, attacking other Khinasi wizards, or talking with the dead.
Otherwise, Khinasi wizards would never be able to learn new things for those wizards who live outside of their lands. And as they are supposed to preserve and protect all knowledge, and people certainly constitute as sources of knowledge, killing them would violate that idea.
At 08:54 AM 5/30/2004 +0200, anacreon wrote:
> In a mixed race group, how does one neutralize the Khinasi Wizards Oath
> to destroy all wizards who do not adhere to their four oaths? Can it be
> neutralized?
Well, nobody really knows how the Five Oaths are applied in the first
place, so deciding on how they might be neutralized is a bit of a
problem. I`m of the opinion that magic used to enforce the oaths is the
equivalent of a powerful geas placed upon Khinasi wizards by a magic item
at the ToR that is the BR equivalent of an artifact. Thus, breaking the
oaths would require a suitably powerful magic–on the order of a Wish or
similar magic.
It is, however, possible for Khinasi wizards to interpret the Oaths and
situations in which they are broken in a particularly “legalistic” way,
making the particulars of the situation in a “gray area” as far as the
specific nature of the Oaths are concerned. Where possible I think that
kind of thing goes on quite a bit. If spellcasting that violates one of
the Oaths goes on without the wizard witnessing it or being confronted too
directly with evidence of it then he might be able to turn a blind eye to
the situation. An Anuirean wizard, for instance, who chose to speak with
dead might do so out of the sight and hearing of a Khinasi colleague, then
tell everyone the results of that spell, but not mention exactly how the
information was acquired. Since the Khinasi wizard has no direct knowledge
that the Oath has been broken he`s got “reasonable doubt” about the
situation and is not required to act according to his Oaths.
Gary
IMO the oaths only specifically apply to Khinasi not to other races.
BoM pg 12 “Any Khinasi spellcaster able to command true magic is legally bound to journey to the Temple of Rilni. . . . .Those called to true magic who will not journey to the temple and swear to them are hunted down and slain.”
This seems to imply that it applies to those who ‘reject’ the oaths and not to those who do not know about them.
Now in the party at hand, if the Khinasi wizard had told the non-Khinasi wizard about the responsibilities of being a true wizard (i.e., making the journey and taking the oaths to the god of magic) and the non-Khinasi wizard continued in his practice of defying the intent of the oaths then there could be a real issue.
Otherwise as long as the non-Khinasi didn’t do anything that defied the oaths the Khinasi would have no reason to take any action whatsoever. The non-Khinasi would probably be judged to be ‘inferior’ and not worth the time.
There is a lot of interpretation to be had in some of the oaths - who is the lawful ruler of the land? Is it the present regent or someone else? Just one example.
The real issue with the Oaths would come in regard to elves: are Sidhelien going to accept a humanitarian (mark the irony here) way of action? Guess not.
I also tend to believe that the Oaths only apply to Khinasi. There is no where saying that Anuirean wizards have to obey the oaths. Khinasi have sayim that no one else does, and a very different culture. I don’t think the Temple of Rilni tries to impose its cultural system onto others, just those of the same culture.
So I’d say it’s fine.
However, a Khinasi wizard watching an Anuirean wizard Raise Dead may have issues and attack, but wouldn’t have to base them on the Oaths, but on ‘that’s a crime against humanity’.
Is there any Khinasi wizards thet are at “war” with the Temple of Rilni. Not taking the oath, nd managing to hide them selfes from the Rilni oath wisards???
Originally posted by teloft@Jun 5 2004, 10:04 AM
Is there any Khinasi wizards thet are at “war” with the Temple of Rilni. Not taking the oath, nd managing to hide them selfes from the Rilni oath wisards???
In the Book of Magecraft there is a write up on one, Quirad al-dinn (BoM pg 35)
teloft schrieb:
>This post was generated by the Birthright.net message forum.
> You can view the entire thread at:
> http://www.birthright.net/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=2665
>
> teloft wrote:
> Is there any Khinasi wizards thet are at “war” with the Temple of Rilni. Not taking the oath, nd managing to hide them selfes from the Rilni oath wisards???
>
The renegade Quirad al-Dinn of course who was invented to explain the
cover art of the Book of Magecraft which obviously shows a Khinasi
Wizard raising the dead which no Khinasi Wizard normally would do.
Located in Rjuvik.
bye
Michael
[COLOR=blue][COLOR=blue][COLOR=blue]
I think that something that also should be taken into account is location. If the party includes non-Khinasi and Khinasi wizards and adventures in non-Khinasi lands, then I believe that the arguments above regarding the BoM hold true, and there shouldn’t be an obligation to kill the party member.
However, if the party adventures in Khinasi, then there is the “when in Rome” factor, and the non-Khinasi characters would be politely asked to make the journey to the ToR, refusal would leave them with the option of going back home or be hunted down.
As I do not have teh BoM, what are the 5 Oaths, word for word? (I am entering a situation where my knowledge of them could be pivotal)
Unless they’ve changed/been updated, or there’s another work out there that’s more in-depth, here’s the Five Oaths from the BoM.
- To obey the commands of the lawful ruler of the state.
- To preserve and protect all knowledge.
- To never raise a hand against another mage sworn to the oaths, except as commanded by the liege in lawful war.
- Never to use magic to raise or communicate with the dead.
- To destroy any wielder of true magic who does not abide by these oaths.
thx!
They are also on pgs 54-55 of the BRCS-playtest
I think that most Khinasi Wizards are wise and diplomatic and therefore they will accept the interests and customs of different cultures.
I also think they are snobish and superior so they will think that other cultures are just ‘inferior’ and shouldn’t be kept to the same standards as are the ‘civilized’ people (i.e., Khinasi). But it would be just bad Sayim to point that out to them.
The question is, how binding these oaths are. I tended to see them as the three oaths binding Aes Sedai in Robert Jordan’s “The Wheel of Time” series. If that is so, than Wizards cannot “turn off” their oaths, and they will have to act upon the 5th oath.
Originally posted by anacreon@Jun 10 2004, 12:27 AM
The question is, how binding these oaths are. I tended to see them as the three oaths binding Aes Sedai in Robert Jordan’s “The Wheel of Time” series. If that is so, than Wizards cannot “turn off” their oaths, and they will have to act upon the 5th oath.
The oaths are ultimately binding - that is any who swear to them (at the temple of Rilni) can not go against them.
Having said that they are always subject to interpretation. The oaths are a Khinasi item, only brought up in relation to Khinasi and a very strong connection to Sayim can be seen between the two.
As interpretation goes - if the 10 commandments were considered the equivalent of the 5 oaths what exactly do they mean? For example, where exactly is the line for coveting and admiring drawn?
No matter how you cut it it will always be a matter of DM interpretation on this one - there can be no difinite answer here only opinions.
I have a understanding of the oaths thet can be healpfull to a DM using them, where he dos not want the Khinasi NPC wisard to attack his players.
3rd * To never raise a hand against another mage sworn to the oaths, except as commanded by the liege in lawful war.
5th * To destroy any wielder of true magic who does not abide by these oaths.
.. So in combonation, a mage would not know wether the player is sworn or not exept fyrst consulting the temple, no mater what the player migth say about it. So in order for the mage to be willing to act upon the 5th oath he must fyrst consult the temple. Some wisards migth even opt to jurney on foot to the temple in order to consult the temple. ![]()