On Thu, 2002-12-05 at 13:51, Kenneth Gauck wrote:
> Place theory is a geographical abstraction to explain why cities are where
> they are, and why certain concentric zones of economic activity form around
> them.
Never heard of it - but expected something like it to exist.
>
> The fact that the standard rules allow me to build a trade route from
> Bhalaene to Bheline (adjacent provinces in Ghoere) suggests that people are
> not willing to travel from Bheline to Bhalaene for their trade needs. In
> fact, they would prefer to pay (in aggregate) 5 GB to shift the labor to
> someone else. Not only that, the profit from moving goods about 30 miles is
> 100% of the value of the goods. This presumes standard BR roads. I`m
pretty sure that peasants, making 1 sp per day, cant afford 100% price > increases, and so trade must strictly be a property of the wealthy. But > even still, there just isnt enough wealth to justify 5GB in profit for
moving products 30 miles. If a horse walks 5 mph (per MM) then the average
maximum distance for regular trade is closer to 40 miles, and its going to
amount to something much, much smaller than 5GB between adjacent provinces.
I agree.
Standard BR trade route rules are poor. (let`s be honest)
They tie trade zones and provinces together, and they are too easy to
create and generate far too much GB.
I, personally, restrict them quite severely. A trade route out of
Bheline to anywhere isnt possible. Although trade from Bheline may occur to neighboring provinces in Ghoere, this is subsumed in Bhelines
guild activity.
>
> Place theory uses hexes to map the areas served, because circles overlap.
> Familiar to gamers.
>
> Place theory assumes that in a perfectly flat world without political
> impediments, the distribution would towns, cities, and large cities would be
> regular and evenly distributed. But, the world has an uneven distribution
> of resources, is geographically irregular, and has political boundaries (and
> the varied opportunities that follows from them). So, we also have the
> Transportation Principle and the Political Principle.
Interesting, the theory seems to mirror exactly how I have restricted
trade. This is a real theory? Can I have a reference to back up my
arbitrary trade decisions please?
The transportation
> principle states that cities on major transportation routes (roads, rivers,
> coastlines) will be larger because a greater proportion of economic activity
> makes use of these transportation routes, and that cities and towns which
> are not on such routes will be smaller than they would otherwise be. The
> political principle is similar in its effect, but is based on the
> differential opportunities of different political environments. For
> example, Jaison Raenech is hostile to his major guilder, seems harsh in all
> his laws, and generally does not promote trade. This inhibits all economic
> activity, making the minimum necessary market larger to overcome this
> obstacle. Aerenwe, on the other hand, has a less restrictive ruler, a
> peolpe who worship the godess of the ocean, and can be expected to divert
> some of that economic activity away from Brothendar, Algael, and Spiritsend,
> and into Dhoenel and Calrie. Given a choice to do business on either side
> of the unnamed river that flows between the two realms,
Spirit River poss ?
Spirit`s End
the political
principle tells us to expect that towns and cities are smaller in Osoerde
than in its neighbors, most of whom are politicaly much friendlier to trade
and the guilders in action there.
So every town and city has a hinterland. The towns hinterland is the rural > area around them. They are a market for agricultural produce and provide a > market for craftsmen who serve the whole hinterland. Small cities will have > several towns in its hinterland. It will act as a town itself, but also as > a catchment area for services that are not provided in the towns itself. > Every town will have a butcher, but perhaps only the cities will have > dedicated spice merchants. Every town will have carpenters who can make a > door or a chest, but only in cities are there locksmiths. Finally there are > the large cities who have a group of smaller cities in their catchment > areas. These cities will provide services not found even in the small > cities, such as banking, or bookselling. > > So lets look at the Highland/Overland Traders. Guild Master Ghorien has
level 2 holdings in Alaroine, Maesford, Soutmoor, anmd Cwlldon, and a 3 in
Tenarien. Ghorien has here a penetration into the markets of others here.
All of those except Alaroine are towns, probabaly in the catchment area of
Ghieste. Riumache is identified as a city, but note that it falls on the
River Maesil. So, I imagine a trade route connecting Endier to Ghiere on to
Riumache, and then overland to Bhalaene and on to Ansien. From Ghiere to
Achiese, Master Ghorien controls the trade route and profits from it.
Bhalaene provides the big city services to all of the areas in the
Highland/Overland catchment area. I imagine a large bank with clerks and
bookkeepers, and everything else youve ever seen from a Dutch painting in > which money was displayed on a table. There is a small office in Ghieste, > Alaroine, and Caudraight, but they just function as extentions of the place > where the gold is in Bhalaene. The best craft experts are in Ghieste and > Bhalaene, but there many more in Bhalaene. Factors in Bhalaene buy goods > comming from the east (immediately out of Ansien) and store them in > warehouses for distribution between now and the next caravan. A much > smaller set of warehouses exist in Ghieste. At Ghieste and Bhalaene goods > comming from the west are purchased, but most of these goods continue moving > east. Auditors from Bhalaene keep an eye on holdings throughout Ghoriens
> domain. The archives are in Bhalaene.
Curious, almost 100% identical.
The Birthright Homepage: http://www.birthright.net
Birthright-l Archives: http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
To unsubscribe, send email to LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
with UNSUB BIRTHRIGHT-L in the body of the message.