I like delving into the alien elf thing, but I feel that it’s more a storytelling exercise for a different game. To avoid rewriting domain rules to fit elven differences (and by extension to treat goblins and dwarves very differently, as well), I’d prefer to stick with the Tolkienesque tie-in of the Sidhe. Not humans with pointy ears, really, but still as physical beings with significant reasons to run some form of organized kingdom. To me, that means there are Houses, which implies strong family ties, and since human society is based on families as well, elves aren’t incredibly alien to them. Different enough to be hard to understand, yes, but still governable by the same domain rules.
As for guilds and temples, I agree with prohibiting temples. I’ve considered ideas such as community-based organizations and philosophies, but that really stretches the temple holding concept. I do think the elves have these organizations and tend towards philosophy, but these could be incorporated into law holdings or even source holdings.
The law holding and and guild holdings seem the most abstract and nebulous of the holding types, standing in for many different things. I doubt, for instance, that elves would have the strong association with LAW that these holdings represent; rather, they are points of organization for the elves, whether it be formal Houses or more informal gatherings. With that in mind, I wouldn’t hesitate to allow elves freedom to max out on law holdings (something that is implied as an almost tyrannical thing in the domain rules, leaving “freer” realms such as Mhoried and Roesone and Coeranys with few law holdings as an implication of this freedom; by that reason, elves shouldn’t have any law holdings at all!).
If current action, fortification, and troop costs are maintained, I would also accept letting elven law holdings generate gold like temples–and I would also argue that they ought to have an elven form of guilds. These guilds would be more like informal Moots, gatherings of artisans to share their skills and crafts, and spontaneous groupings of elves devoting themselves to a task–like crafting new shelters, clothing, tools, palaces, towers, fortifications, arms, spells, or gathering or hunting food.
However, I agree with Kgauck that it may be better just to reduce elven costs. Lower troop mustering, no maintenance costs, spontaneous mustering of skilled levies, no need for fortifications (forests “fortified” by default), and many wizards (either Councils or individuals like Counts sharing sources and RP with the regent without reduction in source levels).
The biggest problem with reducing costs, however, is that it gives elven players rather little to do on the realm front. Already they’re fairly isolated from other realms or internal conflicts. They’re missing half the holdings to keep them occupied. And drastically reducing military needs gives them little to spend money on except for sources. So if elven realms basically become landed, uber-powerful wizards, what do they do? They have little conflict within their borders, for what human wizard will strive against the Sidhe for sources in their own realm? They have no need of ley lines within their borders. They can’t Rule their provinces rapidly under most house rules; and if Ruling Provinces was all they had to focus on, elves would reclaim all their lands in short order. It doesn’t make much sense for them to be researching spells constantly, since they probably know most of them anyway.
So what’s an elf to do, short of require extensive GM-devised subplots?
To keep elf players integrated with the rest of the game, I’d let them work an elven version of guilds, implement my suggested change that all sources generate 1/3GB revenue per level (and don’t act as guilds ever), reduce military costs just a little, and have done. Trade will get the elves involved with the others, or at least with dwarves and other elves. They’ll also have the gold to risk expansion or fund plots throughout the human realms.