When I first thumbed through the 3rd Ed. PH, the lack of Weapon Proficiencies stuck out to my horrified eyes. Where had they gone? And why were they missing? It is a step back to first edition that really made no snese to me, or any in my gaming group.
To alleviate this, we simple carried the second edition system of weapon proficiencies forward into 3rd edition. Simple, elegant and slightly modified.
I feel that every adventurer should not be knowledgable in all weapons. Use a sword, the ngo try to use a staff, now go fire a bow, now throw a dart…each one is completly different, and the ability to defend yourself from an attack with the melee weapons are completly different.
Granted, the ability to use a long sword should grant the ability to use a similar weapon (remember the tight group specialization of the Complete Fighters Manual?) Makes a lot of sense, and knowing how to use a long bow would give the ability to use a short bow, but not a sling.
It should be a simple “yes” or “no” as to whether you know how to use the weapon. Penalties if you don’t and a 0-mod if you do. No need to add skill levels, for that would just be one more number to track. Let the ability with the weapon be dictated by character class and level.
Weapon proficiencies could be grouped as follows:
Daggers and Small Blades
** Dagger
** Punching Dagger
** Spiked Gauntlet
** Dart
** Shuriken
** Kukri
Maces and Clubs
** Mace, Light or Heavy
** Morningstar
** Club
** Light Hammer
** Great Club
Staves
** Quarterstaff
** Trident
** Scythe
Flails
** Dire Flail
** Flail, Heavy or Light
** Nunchaku
** Halfling Nunchaku
Axes and Hammers
** Sap
** Hand/Throwing Axe
** Battle Axe
** Great Axe
** War Hammer
** Pick, Heavy or Light
** Dwarven Urgrosh
** Dwarven War Axe
Bows
** Short Bow
** Short Bow, composite
** Long Bow
** Long Bow, composite
Crossbows
** Hand Crossbow
** Crossbow, Heavy or Light
** Repeating Crossbow
Short Blades
** Short Sword
** Scimitar
** Halfling Kama
** Kama
Medium Blades
** Long Sword
** Rapier
Long Blades
** Falchion
** Greatsword
** Bastard Sword
Polearms
** Glaive
** Guisarme
** Halberd
** Long Spear
** Ranseur
Spears
** Half Spear
** Javelin
** Short Spear
Lance
Net
Sling
Whip
Double Weapons
The last four are so difficult to learn that they would be learned each as a seperate skill, and each double weapon would require its own skill.